Understanding Jon Snow's Legitimization in A Song of Ice and Fire and the Game of Thrones Show

In the A Song of Ice and Fire universe, Jon Snow faces a critical challenge: legitimatizing his status as a Stark. This involves understanding the intricate dynamics of parentage, legitimization, political dynamics, and identity, all of which play crucial roles in his journey.

Parentage and Heritage

It is revealed that Jon is the son of Lyanna Stark and Rhaegar Targaryen. This dual heritage significantly complicates his identity in the Stark household. While he was raised as Eddard Stark’s illegitimate son, his royal blood ties are undeniable. Legitimizing his status as a Stark would require formal recognition, typically through a declaration by a ruling authority, akin to the Iron Throne.

Legitimizing Jon as a Stark

To become a legitimate Stark, Jon would need to be formally recognized as one by a ruling authority. This process would involve the consent of the ruling lord or, in the case of the Iron Throne, the recognition from the highest authority. However, his Targaryen blood also poses a significant threat, especially at a time when the Lannisters still reign and Targaryen blood is seen as a potential danger.

Political Dynamics in Westeros

The complex political landscape of Westeros presents a substantial hurdle to Jon's legitimization. The loyalty of the northern houses, especially the remaining Stark banners, would be crucial. If he were to declare himself a Stark or seek legitimization, he would need the support of significant northern lords like Roose Bolton. Opposition from those who fear his Targaryen heritage could obstruct his path to legitimacy.

Identity and Belonging

Jon's character is deeply intertwined with his identity. His place in the Stark family and his commitment to the North and its people have always been a source of conflict. Acceptance as a Stark might conflict with his dedication to the North, raising questions about his northward loyalty. This internal struggle underscores the importance of political maneuvers in legitimizing his status.

Missed Opportunities in the Show

The show diverges significantly from the books, particularly with the events surrounding the Red Wedding. In the books, Robb Stark names Jon as his lawful heir just before the tragedy, essentially legitimizing Jon as a Stark. This moment would have unified the North under a legitimate Stark king with a claim to the Iron Throne. However, the show omits this event, opting for a less cohesive storyline. Had Jon been named king by Robb, he would have inherited the North and potentially become the King of the North with a rightful claim to the Iron Throne.

Significance of Jon's Banner

The banner Jon would fly as King of the North would be a white direwolf on a black field. This fitting symbol is a nod to his nickname, the "White Wolf." While the show doesn't prominently feature this banner, Jon's journey would have been more aligned with the books’ vision. The Stark sigil in the show, a wolf's head on a white field, is actually Ned Stark's banner. The original Stark sigil is a grey wolf on a white or green field, which would have been more fitting for a true Stark king.

Focus on Defeating the White Walkers

Ultimately, Jon Snow's primary focus on defeating the white walkers supersedes his quest for a title. As the King in the North, his declaration as such would have come from the people, not from declaring himself. Titles are bestowed by the people, not exclusively by a formal recognition. This underscores the pragmatic approach Jon would take. His mind is solely on the impending threat, and the titles are secondary.

Conclusion

The path to legitimizing Jon Snow as a Stark presents a complex web of political, familial, and personal challenges. While the show diverges from the books, had these events transpired in the books, they would have unified the North under a legitimate ruler with a clear claim to the throne. Jon's ultimate focus on defeating the white walkers, however, remains the paramount concern, overshadowing the pursuit of titles.

Keywords

Legitimization, Jon Snow, King in the North, Westeros, Roose Bolton