Is the Nikon D200 or D90 Still Worth Buying as a Backup Camera in 2023?

In today's rapidly evolving photography landscape, older cameras like the Nikon D200 and D90 may seem outdated and less attractive as backup options. But what about if you're on a tight budget or looking for a reliable stand-in for your other gear? Let's dive into the pros and cons of these cameras, and explore whether they are still worth buying as a backup camera in 2023.

Overview of the Nikon D200

The Nikon D200 was a popular camera when it was released, but it has now been surpassed by more advanced models. Here are some key points to consider:

Lightweight and Compact: The D200 was one of the first DX-format DSLRs to be both lightweight and relatively compact, making it a preferred option for travel and casual photography. ISO Sensitivity: With ISO sensitivity ranging from 200 to 3200, the D200 could handle low-light conditions reasonably well, though it's definitely a step behind modern implementations. Lens Compatibility: The D200 supports older lenses, making it easier for owners to utilize their existing collections. However, it has limitations with newer lenses. Video Capabilities: Although the D200 can record basic video, its video quality and features are quite limited compared to modern cameras.

Overview of the Nikon D90

The Nikon D90, released in 2008, was an improvement over the D200, but it has also been surpassed by more advanced models. Here’s where it shines:

Better AF System: The D90 introduced an improved autofocus system that was praised for its speed and accuracy. Sensor and Image Quality: While sharing the same sensor as the D300, the D90 was more user-friendly and easier to handle for everyday shooting. Weight and Size: It was lighter and more compact than the D300, making it a good choice for on-the-go shooting. Video and HD Capabilities: The D90 supports HD video, which was a significant feature at the time but is now considered quite basic.

Pros and Cons of Using the D200 or D90 as a Backup Camera

When considering the D200 or D90 as a backup camera, here are some key points to weigh:

Pros

Lightweight and Portable: Both cameras are relatively compact, making them easy to transport and use. Built-in Flexibility: They can use a wide range of lenses, offering flexibility for different shooting scenarios. Economical Option: Both cameras are relatively affordable, making them a cost-effective choice for photographers on a budget.

Cons

Limited Video Quality: Both cameras have basic video capabilities, which may not be sufficient for videographers or those looking for advanced video features. Much Older Technology: The D200 and D90 are nearly 15 years old, and their image quality and performance fall short compared to modern cameras. Battery Issues: The D200 and D90 use older battery formats, which may be difficult to find or expensive when replacements are needed. Lens Support: They support older lenses, but may have compatibility issues with newer ones, limiting the range of lenses you can use.

Alternatives

While the D200 and D90 can fill some backup needs, there are better options on the market:

Nikon D7200

The Nikon D7200 is a much better choice if you are looking for a high-quality backup camera. It offers:

Better Image Quality: The D7200 provides superior image quality compared to the D200 and D90. Faster Autofocus: The D7200 has a faster and more accurate autofocus system. Better Video Capabilities: It supports more advanced video recording features, making it a more versatile choice.

Second Camera Strategy

If you want a more comprehensive solution, consider the "backup body" strategy:

Reasonable Similarity: Choose a camera that is reasonably similar in quality and handling to ensure a better shooting experience. Share Accessories: A complementing camera can share accessories, such as lenses and batteries, making it easier to manage your gear. Varied Usage: Use your main camera for primary shooting and the backup for secondary or specific tasks, creating a versatile and flexible setup.

Conclusion

While the Nikon D200 and D90 were great cameras in their time, they are now outdated and may not be the best choice for a backup camera in 2023. The D7200 offers better image quality, faster autofocus, and more advanced features, making it a more viable option. If budget is a concern, consider the "backup body" strategy to maintain a high-quality backup camera while sharing accessories with your primary camera.