Is There an Anime on MyAnimeList with a Perfect 10 Rating?

The quest for the perfect anime often leads enthusiasts to MyAnimeList (MAL), a platform renowned for its detailed community ratings and reviews. WEB88s query stirs a common debate in the anime community: is there an anime with a perfect 10/10 rating on MAL?

No, There Isn’t a Perfect 10 on MyAnimeList

Unfortunately, perfection is a rare occurrence in the world of anime, even though many shows are beloved and highly rated. The highest-rated anime on MyAnimeList is Gintama, currently holding a 9.0 rating. This indicates that while some series can come very close to perfection, achieving the elusive perfect 10 is nearly impossible. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, which is highly acclaimed, has received the second-highest rating, but it too falls short of the perfect 10. Even beloved shows like Clannad After Story, Fullmetal Alchemist, SteinsGate, Violet Evergarden, and Naruto have not achieved the perfect 10.

Why the Perfect 10 Is Rare

There are several reasons why achieving a perfect 10 rating on MAL is rare. First, the sheer volume of users contributing to the ratings can make it nearly impossible for every single viewer to rate a series with perfect scores. For instance, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood received over a million votes, making it statistically unlikely that all viewers would rate it with a perfect score. Second, even the most beloved and well-regarded anime series have minor flaws that detract from the overall experience, no matter how minute or well-tolerated these imperfections may be. The nature of critical review and user opinions means that personal biases and preferences play a significant role in determining a series' rating.

The Debate Over Perfection

The debate over the perfect 10 rating is a curious one. WEB88b argues that the existence of such a perfect score would be impossible, as it would imply that 100% of viewers found the show flawless. This viewpoint is underpinned by the idea that no creative work can be perfect, and that even highly rated shows must have some form of flaw. However, this perspective is countered by others who believe that a perfect 10 is a representation of a series that excels in all aspects, from storytelling to animation, and that it is subjective in nature.

Conclusion: The Quest for Perfection

While perfect 10 ratings are rare on MyAnimeList, their pursuit is a testament to the high standards and deep passion within the anime community. Whether the highest rating is 9.0 or 9.9, these scores reflect the amazing quality and craftsmanship of the anime industry. It is a reminder that in the world of anime, as in any art form, perfection is an ideal, and the journey to achieving it is as much about the experience as the destination.