Is Starting Dwayne Haskins in a Terrible Offensive Line a Smart Move for the Washington Commanders?

Washington Commanders fans might be wondering if it's wise for the team to start Dwayne Haskins in the upcoming season, especially with their current offensive line issues.

While the idea of having an unquestioned star quarterback like Haskins leading the team might be enticing, it's important to consider the potential risks. First and foremost, a poor offensive line can seriously harm a quarterback's performance and longevity. As evidenced by the tragic leg injuries suffered by Alex Smith, Colt McCoy, and even Haskins himself, a weak offensive front is a recipe for disaster.

Case Keenum: A Solid Option in a Crumbling Offensive Line

Instead of rushing Haskins into the starting role, the Washington Commanders might want to give Case Keenum more time to develop. Keenum has shown steady performance, especially when compared to other veteran quarterbacks like Andy Dalton, Joe Flacco, and Eli Manning. Even though he hasn't had a breakout season, he has consistently put up average to above-average numbers.

At 31 years old, Keenum still has a few more years left as a potential starter. If he continues to perform well, he could command significant free-agent dollars. As a seasoned veteran, Keenum is also more capable of handling the pressure of a poor offensive line, which is something Haskins, a relatively inexperienced quarterback, is not ready for.

Delaying Haskins' Start and Focusing on Offensive Line Improvement

So, what should the Washington Commanders do in the short term? If their goal is to have a championship-quality offense in the long run, they need to address their weak offensive line. Trading for a star offensive lineman or drafting a highly touted prospect in the upcoming draft is a necessary step.

Once the offensive line is stronger, Keenum can serve as a proven, reliable starter. This would allow Haskins to focus on developing his skills without the added pressure of an underwhelming offensive line. Keenum can then act as a mentor to Haskins, teaching him the nuances of the game and helping him navigate the pressures of the NFL.

Strategic Approach to QB Development and Line Reinforcement

For the 2023 season, the Washington Commanders should focus on making their offensive line more formidable. This could involve re-signing Trent Williams or finding a star player through trades or the draft. Once the line is solidified, Keenum can maintain his role as the primary starter, while Haskins can replace him in 2024 when Keenum moves on.

By not rushing Haskins into a poor offensive line, the Commanders can protect their investment and ensure both Haskins and the team are set up for long-term success. This strategic approach also allows for a smoother transition, as the team will have a more reliable and experienced quarterback to guide Haskins through his development.

In conclusion, while Dwayne Haskins has the potential to become an elite quarterback, the current offensive line issues pose a significant risk. Delaying his start and focusing on improving the offensive line is the most sensible strategy. This approach prioritizes both player safety and long-term team success.