The Belief in Snoke as Darth Plagueis: A Speculative Theory

The internet and fan communities are abuzz with the theory that Supreme Leader Snoke of The Rise of Skywalker is actually Darth Plagueis, a character mentioned in Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones. While this speculation adds an appealing layer of complexity to the Star Wars universe, there is no official confirmation from Lucasfilm or Disney about this theory.

Why the Snoke-Darth Plagueis Connection Falls Flat

One of the main arguments against this theory is that Darth Plagueis does not carry significance within the Star Wars narrative. Despite his role in tempting Anakin Skywalker to the dark side of the Force, Plagueis is quickly marginalized as a character. The Force lineage he proposed is a mere academic exercise rather than an actual plot device. As a result, revealing Snoke as Darth Plagueis would not significantly enrich the story, as most viewers would be unfamiliar with this character.

Impact on Narrative Development

Narrative impact is often a crucial factor in Star Wars storytelling. In The Rise of Skywalker, the revelation that Rey was Palpatine's granddaughter was met with indifference by many viewers because it lacked context or personal connection. Similarly, identifying Snoke as Darth Plagueis would fall flat as well because characters like Rey and Kylo Ren have no pre-existing knowledge or history with Plagueis.

The Original Theory's Strengths and Weaknesses

While the Snoke-Darth Plagueis connection might not significantly enhance the story, it offers a compelling storyline for fans. If it were to be explored, it could provide more depth to the Sith lineage and introduce new elements of the dark side, such as Sith Alchemy and the manipulation of midichlorians. However, the narrative would still face several challenges:

Continuity and Plot Consistency: If Plagueis is revealed to still be alive, it introduces a significant continuity error. Given that Anakin Skywalker, who had a relationship with Plagueis (an ancestor of Darth Sidious), is now dead, this revelation would require a strong explanation to maintain the timeline. Character Development: The betrayal of his apprentice, Anakin, and the subsequent "death" of Plagueis could serve as a foundation for exploring Sith Alchemy. It would also provide insights into the political landscape of the Empire and the Rebel Alliance. Explaining Plagueis' Survival: Plagueis' survival would necessitate an in-depth explanation. Whether it's through on-screen dialogue, novels, or comics, the story needs to justify how he managed to cheat death.

From a fan perspective, a storyline involving Plagueis could indeed be intriguing. However, the execution would need to be precise and well-thought-out to avoid continuity issues and to provide a satisfying new layer to the Star Wars universe.

Conclusion

The Snoke-Darth Plagueis theory, while entertaining in theory, does not add significant value to the Star Wars narrative. The central issue lies in the lack of connection between these characters and the existing storyline. Even with new revelations, the plot holes and continuity issues would need to be meticulously addressed.

As an SEO for Google, I would recommend content around the topic of Star Wars speculation, providing informative and engaging analysis that adds value to the current narrative, such as exploring the impact of unconfirmed fan theories and their potential implications for the Star Wars universe.