Is Sherlock Holmes’ Action-Oriented Portrayal in Recent Films Suitable for the Character?

In the recent film adaptations of Sherlock Holmes, such as those featuring Robert Downey Jr. (RDJ), there is a recurring debate about the balance between action and intellect in portraying the character. Critics argue that RDJ’s take on Sherlock Holmes is overly action-oriented, neglecting the core traits of the original literary character. Conversely, others argue that the inclusion of action scenes in the Holmes films is not only appropriate but is a part of the character as depicted in earlier incarnations, including classic film versions.

RDJ's Interpretation: Overly Action-Oriented?

Some viewers and critics have expressed concern that RDJ's Sherlock Holmes is too action-packed, highlighting moments such as his speed in "The Hound of the Baskervilles" and his boxing skills in "The Solitary Cyclist." Proponents of this view argue that RDJ's focus on these physical feats detracts from the character's intellectual and deductive prowess. While these elements are undoubtedly entertaining, they may overshadow the meticulous reasoning and aloof demeanor that are the hallmark of what we know as Sherlock Holmes from Arthur Conan Doyle's stories.

The Real Sherlock Holmes

Upon closer inspection, it becomes clear that the Sherlock Holmes of the classic stories is multifaceted. Deductive reasoning is just one aspect of the character; his intelligence, sharp wit, and action-oriented nature are equally significant. For instance, in the classic film "The Hound of the Baskervilles" (1939), starring Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce, Holmes and Watson engage in an intense action sequence that showcases Holmes' dynamic and resourceful side.

Rathbone's Action-Driven Sherlock

One of the best illustrations of historically-authentic action in the Holmes films is the 1939 version of "The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes." In this film, there is a climactic confrontation that vividly demonstrates Holmes' action capabilities. Skip to the 1:13 mark in the film, where Holmes calls out to Watson about the Crown Jewels. The ensuing action is relentless, with Holmes and Watson racing through London in a hansom cab, engaging in chase scenes, shooting exchanges, and hand-to-hand combat with Moriarty. This sequence is a testament to Rathbone's portrayal of a character who is both a brilliant detective and a formidable action hero.

Despite being filmed in 1939, the action scenes in this film are considered appropriate and not out-of-place for the traditional depiction of Holmes. This suggests that action realism was an accepted part of the character's portrayal even during the early days of cinema.

Conclusion

The debate around Sherlock Holmes' action-oriented portrayal is ongoing. While RDJ's interpretation of the character may be seen by some as an overemphasis on physical action, it is important to recognize that the character has always had multiple dimensions. Classic film versions like Basil Rathbone's incarnation provide a counterpoint, demonstrating that action scenes have a rightful place in the character's repertoire.

Ultimately, the true Sherlock Holmes is a well-rounded character—part intellect, part action hero. Whether through deduction or derring-do, the excitement and intensity of Holmes’ adventures can enrich the experience for modern audiences while honoring Arthur Conan Doyle's richly-drawn original.