Is Rey Palpatine’s Granddaughter in The Rise of Skywalker?

viewers of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker have been left questioning the true origins of Rey. Specifically, the reveal that she is Palpatine’s granddaughter has sparked a lot of discussion. This debate goes beyond mere curiosity; it delves into the heart of the film’s narrative and character development. Let's explore why this revelation is considered controversial and how it intertwines with the overall storyline.

Controversial Reveal and Characters’ Origins

During the film, Kylo Ren reveals to Rey that she is Palpatine’s granddaughter. This revelation was initially seen as a grand twist, reminiscent of the iconic “I am your father” line in Return of the Jedi. However, upon closer examination, many find this reveal underwhelming and question its relevance to the characters' backstories and the overarching plot.

Character Backstories and Continuity

One of the main arguments against Rey being Palpatine’s granddaughter is the disconnect it creates with the characters' backstories and the narrative. Specifically, Luke’s long-held belief that his father, Anakin Skywalker, was a Jedi and his subsequent hatred of Darth Vader are recontextualized in a way that feels forced.

“It was always a ruse. An actor’s performance. I am your father. It was never meant to be proven.” - Darth Vader in Return of the Jedi

The reveal that Anakin was not Palpatine's true self but rather his descendant adds another layer of complexity, but it also feels like a convoluted plot device rather than a natural progression in the story.

Authenticity and Credibility

Additionally, the revelation raises questions about its authenticity. Kylo Ren and Darth Sidious are both known for their manipulation, leading to skepticism about their motivations. Kylo’s revelation could be seen as a tactic to undermine Rey, while Darth Sidious’s words could be influenced by his intention to manipulate Rey further.

“You are a Palpatine. You will understand this.” - Darth Sidious to Rey

This ambiguity adds an interesting facet to the narrative but also makes the revelation less impactful and credible.

The Use of Sith Legacy

The idea of Palpatine’s legacy continuing through Rey is deeply rooted in the Sith’s influence on both sides of the Force. Palpatine, as the ultimate Sith lord, often chose his heirs carefully. His choice of Luke as a protege and later Rey as his granddaughter continues this lineage of power.

From a purely narrative standpoint, the Sith legacy being carried forward adds a sense of grandeur and continuity. However, from a character development perspective, it strips Rey of her identity and autonomy, making her feel more like a pawn in the larger Sith plan rather than a protagonist with agency.

Fan Reception and Analysis

fan reception to this reveal was largely mixed. While some were excited by the grandeur of the reveal and its potential implications for the continuing saga, others found it to be a missed opportunity. The underwhelming impact of the reveal on the audience suggests that it did not resonate with viewers as a significant plot twist.

“While the reveal was significant, it felt more like a strategic move by the filmmakers to close the chapter on the Skywalker saga rather than an organic development in the story.” - Stringent Star Wars Fan

The reveal in The Rise of Skywalker also highlights the broader narrative issues within the sequel trilogy, where key plot points often felt disconnected and rushed. Rey’s unknown parentage, which served as a profound narrative choice in The Last Jedi, was reversed to make her a Palpatine, which many feel undermined her character arc.

Conclusion and Reflection

The revelation that Rey is Palpatine’s granddaughter remains a contentious point in the Star Wars saga. While it adds a layer of complexity to the mythology, it ultimately takes more away from Rey's own identity and character development. This raises questions about the film's true intentions and the clarity of its storytelling.

As a devoted Star Wars fan, it’s understandable to feel frustrated and disappointed with the narrative choices made in The Rise of Skywalker. However, it's also important to recognize the film’s place in the larger narrative and the potential for future stories to explore and expand upon this intriguing revelation.

Peace and Love.