Is P.R. Sondhi, Wrestling Coach of the Phogat Sisters, Really as Maligned as Portrayed in Dangal?

P.R. Sondhi, the coach of the iconic Phogat sisters, has been a controversial figure, particularly due to his portrayal in the film Dangal. The movie has fueled debates and stirred up various perspectives about his coaching methods and actions.

Controversial Portrayal in Dangal

Dangal, starring Aamir Khan, has dramatically portrayed the harsh realities faced by the Phogat sisters under Sondhi's coaching. While Sondhi's portrayal in the film has been criticized and questioned, it is essential to acknowledge that a movie, even one as acclaimed as Dangal, is not a true reflection of reality but a creative interpretation tailored to fit the narrative and emotions the filmmakers wanted to convey.

However, the film's depiction of Sondhi in Dangal isn't entirely without basis. P.R. Sondhi had served as the official coach of Geeta Phogat and Babita Phogat during the 2010 Commonwealth Games. His reputation and methods during this period have been scrutinized.

Personal Opinions and Real-World Context

It is quite natural for people to form opinions based on the portrayal in the movie. However, judging Sondhi merely based on Dangal would be an oversimplification. The Indian audience often relies on films that add a layer of spice to their storytelling. The movie Dangal certainly adds this layer, making the story more engaging and relatable.

Michael Werner, the biographer of Geeta and Babita Phogat, has praised the movie for its truthful portrayal of their experiences in the wrestling realm. However, it's essential to recognize that the filmmakers had certain creative liberties to make the story more compelling. The movie focuses on the highlights of the sisters' struggles and emotional journey, rather than providing an exhaustive timeline of every detail.

Actual vs. Hyperbolic Portrayal

Geeta Phogat's real-life journey to winning a medal in the first round of the tournament at the 2010 Commonwealth Games is a testament to the film's authenticity. The depiction of her early achievements and the challenges she faced, as portrayed in the movie, aligns closely with her real-life events.

It is noteworthy that P.R. Sondhi's role in the Phogat sisters' journey is indeed nuanced. The film presents Sondhi as someone who was both instrumental in their success and, at times, harsh and rigid in his coaching methods. while some might argue that his strictness was necessary for their success, others might argue that his methods were overly harsh. Regardless, the film's creators have gone to lengths to present Sondhi in grey shades, suggesting a more complex and realistic portrayal rather than a one-dimensional villain.

Real-Life Implications and Reactions

Real-life coach P.R. Sondhi has expressed his dissatisfaction with the filmmakers of Dangal. He feels that the film has distorted his character and actions, leading to a performative unhappiness that doesn't align with reality. These feelings are understandable, as he has invested time and resources in the young wrestlers he coached.

Despite some public backlash, there have been no official accusations brought against the filmmakers for the portrayal of Sondhi. This suggests that the filmmakers have portrayed him within the bounds of what they believed to be the truth of the events and the character's experiences. While this doesn't fully absolve Sondhi of any perceived malpractices, it does highlight the complexity of the situation.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the portrayal of P.R. Sondhi in Dangal has sparked controversy, it is crucial to view this portrayal within the context of the film's artistic liberties and the nuanced realities of the coaching environment in India. The film's vivid depiction of the Phogat sisters' journey, including their encounters with Sondhi, serves as a reflection of a broader issue in Indian sports—where the welfare of athletes is overshadowed by the aspirations and benefits of coaches and organizations.

While it is possible that P.R. Sondhi did wrong to the Phogat sisters, the ultimate truth might never be fully known without a detailed, factual account of what transpired during their working relationship. For now, the movie remains a powerful narrative, capturing the essence of their journey and the controversies that have surrounded it.