Is Monsterverse Godzilla Just Complete Trash: A Critical Analysis

In the world of kaiju films, the MonsterVerse has garnered both praise and criticism. While some fans passionately argue that the series is 'complete trash,' others defend it as a valuable contribution to the Godzilla franchise. This article will delve into the arguments surrounding the series, with a particular emphasis on the question of Godzilla's invincibility and its impact on fan reactions.

The Argument of Invincibility

One of the most contentious aspects of the MonsterVerse is the fact that Longonga (Godzilla) does not die. Critics argue that this immortality discredits the series and makes it unpalatable for dedicated Godzilla fans. The logic goes that if the titular character never faces a permanent end, the films become predictable and lose their dramatic impact.

For instance, Kong: Skull Island faced considerable backlash from Kong fans when Godzilla: King of the Monsters killed Kong without intending to. This suggests a similar fate for Longonga in the future would indeed alienate some fans and harm the series' reception.

Fan Perceptions and Behavior

However, the reality painted by experienced Facebook group administrators is more nuanced. According to these administrators, King Kong fans often exhibit immature behavior and are quick to lash out, while Godzilla fans are portrayed as more open-minded and respectful. This suggests that the issue may not lie solely with the content but rather with the mindset of certain fans.

One administrator even went so far as to ban several Kong fans for their abusive behavior, including threatening violence and posting offensive memes. This example underscores the importance of maintaining a respectful online community and the challenges faced by pursuing a diverse fan base.

Storytelling and Character Continuity

The argument that Godzilla's immortality is a fundamental storytelling device deserves consideration. In the realm of fiction, the protagonist often remains alive to tell more stories. This is a timeless trope in literature and film, seen in various forms, from King Kong to Vampires. The continuation of the story is a key factor in keeping a franchise alive.

Furthermore, the deaths in films such as Doctor Who and Planet of the Monsters are ultimately negated, allowing the characters to return in new forms. This dynamic is particularly evident in the Godzilla universe, where the concept of 'singular points' could enable Longonga's return even after apparent death.

It is not uncommon for slasher villains to remain alive, so the idea that the hero should face permanent death is often seen as a contrivance. This perpetuates the cycle of storytelling and allows for new adventures and conflicts, maintaining the audience's interest.

Is the MonsterVerse Worthwhile?

While Godzilla's invincibility may be a contentious issue, the MonsterVerse has seen significant development over time. Early films, such as Godzilla: Resurgence, faced criticism, but subsequent installments have improved in quality and complexity. This evolution reflects the genre's inherent challenges, including balancing fan expectations with artistic vision.

It is true that the MonsterVerse contains a segment of fans who are particularly vocal and resistant to change. However, this is a common phenomenon in all fan communities. It is essential to acknowledge and engage with these fans while also striving to evolve and innovate in the franchise.

Conclusion

The question of whether the MonsterVerse is complete trash or a valuable addition to the Godzilla franchise is not straightforward. Godzilla's immortality is part of a larger narrative strategy, but it is not the sole determiner of the series' quality. While some fans may find the concept frustrating, the MonsterVerse has shown growth and improvement over time. Ultimately, the ongoing battle between fan loyalty and creative innovation will shape the future of this beloved franchise.