Is JAWS the Best Shark Film Ever? Debating the Ultimate Horror Classic

When it comes to shark films, the question Is JAWS the best shark film ever? often arises. While opinions are divided, many argue that JAWS stands above its sequels and other shark-themed cinema, cementing its place as a classic. In this article, we explore the reasons why some believe JAWS is the pinnacle of the genre and compare it to other notable shark films.

The Skeptics and Defenders of JAWS

Some film enthusiasts argue that JAWS (1975) is indeed the best shark film ever, surpassing its sequels and even other notable shark films. Critics like Christopher Bennett and Scott Leal assert that JAWS is not just among the best, but arguably the only good shark film due to its focus on genuine excitement, storyline, and characterisation.

The Reliability of the Mechanical Shark

A common critique of JAWS is that its success was partly due to the unreliable mechanical shark. While this is true, the film's director, Steven Spielberg, is believed to have realized that placing the camera in the point of view (POV) of the shark would be far more terrifying than viewing it from the outside. This innovative approach effectively explores the unseeable horror, making the audience experience a more unrelenting fear. As stated by Leal, this approach is what sets JAWS apart.

The Characters and Chemistry

Interestingly, the emphasis on characterisation and chemistry is often highlighted as a crucial element of JAWS. Contrary to what some might think, JAWS is not just about the shark— it's about the compelling characters and their interactions. According to Bennett, the characters in JAWS are as interesting as those in any other great horror film. This is a fundamental difference from many of its sequels and other shark films, which often lack the depth and complexity of their main characters.

The Terrors of JAWS

The impact of JAWS transcends mere cinematic value; it has the power to profoundly affect viewers' perception of sharks. For some, like Jane Doe (a pseudonym), JAWS is so terrifying that it keeps them from the ocean for months or even years. This real-life example demonstrates the film's lasting impact and how it taps into deep-seated fears.

Doe recalls an instance where she and her boyfriend, a teenager at the time, were so terrified of the film that it took weeks for her boyfriend to feel comfortable returning to sleeping with his feet near the edge of the bed. This underscores the psychological impact of JAWS, which can linger long after the film is over.

Comparisons with Other Shark Films

However, there are those who feel that JAWS has been unfairly appropriated by other shark-themed films. While JAWS is undoubtedly a masterpiece, some believe that other films have piggybacked on its popularity. According to Sam Smith, while JAWS is arguably the best horror film starring an animal, other films have used its success to market their own, often less compelling, versions.

Alternative Perspectives

Not everyone agrees that JAWS is the best shark film ever. Robert Johnson believes that Blue Water White Death (1966) is the best shark film ever. This lesser-known film, which inspired Peter Benchley's novel, The Deep, which in turn inspired JAWS, is a stark reminder that there are other films in the genre that are equally, if not more, terrifying.

Johnson states, 'I have watched “Jaws” a number of times and enjoyed it every time. Great cast, Spielberg directing, good storytelling.' However, his personal experience with Blue Water White Death is so impactful that he finds it the best shark film ever. If you have not experienced this film, it is definitely worth a look for a fresh perspective on the shark genre.

Conclusion

While JAWS is widely regarded as an iconic and terrifying film, it is not without its critics. Whether it's the best shark film ever is a matter of personal opinion, but there's no denying its significant impact on the genre. From its innovative use of perspective to its deeply engaging characters, JAWS continues to stand as a landmark in horror cinema. Whether you agree or disagree, exploring other shark films in the genre can offer a richer understanding and appreciation of the genre's scope and depth.

By delving into the history and impact of JAWS, we can appreciate why it has become such a beloved and respected film. Whether you consider JAWS the best shark film ever or not, it remains a cornerstone of horror and thriller films that continue to inspire and terrify audiences.