Is '13 Reasons Why' Season 4 Worth Watching During Lockdown?

Season 4 of the controversial Netflix series '13 Reasons Why' has sparked a heated debate among its audience. While some found it engaging, many were disappointed and even alarmed by the plot developments. This article explores the key aspects that make this season controversial and whether it's worth watching.

Key Characters and Plot Developments

The fourth season does not live up to the highs set by the previous episodes, introducing several new characters and plot twists that some viewers found disturbing. Major concerns include:

Clay Jensen: Played out as a psychopathic and irresponsible character, Clay's actions are both unpredictable and disturbing. Despite hallucinating ghosts of Bruce and Monty, he continues to break rules and laws with impunity, making him an enigma. Zach Dempsey: A recurring character portrayal that remains unclear, as his storyline transitions between moments of clarity and binge drinking. Diego and Jessica: Their complex relationship, marked by mutual faking and implied breakup, adds complexity but little clarity to the narrative. Ani and Charlie: An endearing pair in the series, their storyline is relatively positive and keeps the audience engaged compared to the others.

Critiques and Analysis

Much of the criticism surrounding this season centers around the following points:

1. Overly Discussed Mental Health and Ethical Issues

Clay, who is portrayed with a disassociative disorder, commits a series of illegal acts and dangerous behaviors without facing any consequences. This makes the character appear both flippant and traumatized, creating a chaotic and unsettling narrative. Comments on the show's portrayal of mental health, ethics, and legal issues are mixed, with some praising the complexity and others finding it irresponsible.

2. Lack of Plot Focus and Stagnant Storytelling

Marketing strategies for the season emphasized a high degree of drama with promises of plot twists, but the reality often fell flat. Viewers complained about the abundance of filler episodes that do not significantly impact the storyline or themes. This lack of rigorous plotting has led many to feel the season is less impactful than the earlier seasons.

3. Mixed Reactions to Character Development

While some characters, like Ani, sparked positivity, the overall character development across the board was seen as a significant issue. The portrayal of mental illness, complex relationships, and ethical dilemmas was inconsistent and sometimes over-the-top, making it difficult for viewers to connect with the characters on a deeper level.

Is It Worth Binge-Watching?

The decision to watch Season 4 ultimately comes down to personal preference. For those who enjoyed S1, S2, and S3, the season may still hold value, but it's clear that it does not meet the expectations set by earlier installments. The dramatic and often chaotic storyline, coupled with several problematic elements, might not appeal to everyone, particularly those sensitive to themes of depression and suicide.

However, for those interested in exploring the complexities of mental health, ethical dilemmas, and the struggles faced by young adults, there might be enough depth to warrant the binge-watching.

Conclusion

Whether '13 Reasons Why' Season 4 is worth watching during these lockdown days largely depends on your tolerance for its controversial elements and unconventional storytelling. While some may find it engaging and instructive, others might find it overwhelming and unpleasant. It's a show that requires a balanced approach to mental health and ethical issues, making it a polarizing choice among viewers.