Intelligence in Battle: Who Would Win, Robb Stark or Stannis Baratheon?

When it comes to strategic and tactical intelligence, Robb Stark and Stannis Baratheon are two formidable adversaries with distinct strengths and weaknesses. Stannis has managed to crush larger forces, hold fortresses, and outmaneuver his opponents with strategic and tactical brilliance. Meanwhile, Robb has proven his prowess in battle through his own tactical acumen and strategic foresight.

Stannis Baratheon: A Master of Strategy and Logistics

During the Greyjoy rebellion, Stannis not only defeated the formidable iron fleet but also managed to blockade and ultimately capture the fortress of Storm’s End for over a year. His subsequent victories over Renly Baratheon and the King Beyond the Wall showcase his strategic prowess and tactical fortitude. Even when outnumbered nearly 20 to 1 against the ironborn, Stannis managed to secure a decisive victory. His ability to rally half of the Northern lords and even get the renowned Roose Bolton on his side within a few months is a testament to his strategic acumen.

Robb Stark: A Masterful Tactician

Robb Stark, the Young Wolf, has shown his tactical brilliance repeatedly. He defeated the Freys at the Battle of the Whispering Wood, capturing Jamie Lannister. Despite his own tactical victories, Robb has faced challenges, such as being betrayed by the Freys. However, Robb's ability to adapt to different battlefields and enemies, including his victory against Tywin Lannister, demonstrates his strategic and tactical intelligence.

The Importance of Intelligence in Battle

The term "intelligence in battle" extends beyond just tactical and strategic skill. It encompasses strategic planning, the ability to choose the right time, place, and method to engage in battle, and logistical expertise. Logistical support, such as adequate supply and reinforcement, is often the most critical factor in ensuring a victory.

While Robb Stark has proven to be an exceptional tactician and competent strategist, particularly against Tywin Lannister, the latter is not a significant challenge for Stannis. The Young Wolf has yet to face a commander with a habitual ability to constantly reinforce his army, like Tywin Lannister. This suggests that, in a direct battle, Robb might have the edge, but there are compelling reasons why Stannis would not agree to such an asymmetric contest.

Logistical Chess: The Weapons of War

In terms of long-term war strategy, logistics play a crucial role. Stannis's ability to continue to supply his forces and maintain his lines of communication even while under siege is impressive. Stannis would likely try to outmaneuver Robb and harass his supply lines, forcing Robb to engage in conditions of the Baratheon's choosing. This is a scenario where Stannis's superior logistical expertise and strategic intelligence would likely give him the upper hand.

In conclusion, while Robb Stark is a formidable enemy and a masterful tactician, the complexities of a prolonged war and the critical role of logistics mean that Stannis Baratheon would likely have the strategic and logistical edge in a prolonged conflict.