In 'How to Train Your Dragon 2': Would Hiccup Have Tried to Kill Toothless if He Knew the Outcome?

As one delves into the intricate narrative of 'How to Train Your Dragon 2', a particularly haunting scene unfolds. This moment occurs when Drago Brainwashes Toothless, leading to a horrifying turn of events where Toothless even attempts to kill Hiccup. But what if Hiccup had known the dire consequences of refusing to do the same? Would he have taken the same path?

Tangled Emotions and Sacrificial Loyalties

The primary emotion that emerges from analyzing this scenario is the complex interplay of love, loyalty, and sacrifice. As a central character in the film, Hiccup's relationships are woven into his narrative as intricately as the fabric of dragon armor.

Seemingly, Hiccup's bond with Toothless is unbreakable. Toothless has always been his loyal companion and friend, a constant presence in his life. However, Hiccup's love for his father, Stoick, also holds significant weight. This deep familial bond is not easily discarded. While his love for Toothless is almost unconditional, Hiccup's sense of familial duty is equally profound.

The Stakes Are High

The question at hand revolves around the consequences of Hiccup's actions. In the film, Hiccup chooses to save Toothless, knowing full well the risks involved. This decision ultimately leads to the tragic fate of Stoick, his father. This fact doesn't make the decision any less noble—it only adds layers of complexity to the story.

However, what if Hiccup had been presented with the knowledge that saving Toothless would cost his father's life? Would he have still made the choice? This hypothetical scenario adds a layer of morality to the narrative, forcing viewers to consider the depth of Hiccup's character and the weight of his choices.

Character Depth and Complexity

The decision-making process of the protagonist in 'How to Train Your Dragon 2' speaks volumes about their character. It highlights the intricate moral dilemmas and the immense burden of responsibility that Hiccup carries throughout the film. Hiccup, despite his young age, is portrayed as a figure of immense courage and intelligence.

Toothless, on the other hand, is shown to have a profound understanding of loyalty and sacrifice. His actions in the film, particularly when brainwashed, create a stark contrast to the reality of his true nature. This further emphasizes the sacrifices and the deep bonds that exist between Hiccup and his dragon.

The Broader Implications

Beyond the immediate emotional impact of this hypothetical scenario, it also raises questions about the nature of loyalty and the extent to which one would go to protect their loved ones. The narrative of 'How to Train Your Dragon 2' posits that sometimes, the highest acts of love and loyalty come in the form of sacrifice.

This theme is not unique to the film. In numerous works of fiction and real life, characters face similar dilemmas, forced to make life-altering choices in the name of the greater good. The choices made by Hiccup and Toothless in the film are no different. They challenge us to think deeply about the nature of love and the lengths we, as individuals, are willing to go to protect and save those we hold dear.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the question of whether Hiccup would have tried to kill Toothless if he knew that refusing to do so would result in his father's death is one that resonates deep within the narrative of 'How to Train Your Dragon 2'. It delves into the complex emotional landscape of the characters and forces viewers to reconsider the depth of their connections. This scenario highlights the profound sacrifices made by Hiccup and Toothless, making their character development all the more poignant and memorable.