What Would Have Happened if Radagast the Brown Had Joined the Fellowship of the Ring?

Radagast, also known as Radagast the Brown, is one of the Istari, also known as Wizards, mentioned in J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings. Though often overshadowed by the more prominent Gandalf, Radagast plays a significant role in Middle-earth's ecosystem and history. This article explores the potential impact if Radagast had joined the Fellowship of the Ring.

Radagast's Powers and Influence

Radagast the Brown has a unique relationship with nature and animals. While not as powerful as Gandalf the White, Radagast's influence over birds and wildlife is undeniable. He is known for his ability to communicate with and control animals, and he once harnessed the Eagles to aid in the Fellowship's journey, specifically for keeping watch over them. However, his influence is often seen as subtle, and he is frequently overlooked in the storyline.

One of the key instances where Radagast shows his prowess is when he sends the Eagles to Gwaihir to give a message to Gandalf, which results in Gandalf's escape from Orthanc. Radagast also plays a crucial role in maintaining the order of the Istari, as he marshals animals in collecting and disseminating information.

The Role of Radagast in Middle-earth

Radagast is often seen as a character who operates in the shadow of more prominent figures like Gandalf and Saruman. His primary duty seems to be to maintain the balance of nature and protect the flora and fauna of Middle-earth. While he does not actively engage in the struggle against Sauron, his role is vital to the ecosystem and the survival of Middle-earth.

If Radagast were to join the Fellowship, his presence would have added a unique perspective to their journey. He would likely suggest the use of animals and birds for transportation and communication, much like the Eagles. His ability to communicate with these creatures would undoubtedly have made the Fellowship's journey more efficient and safer.

A Speculative Scenario: Radagast in the Fellowship

Imagine Radagast being formally introduced to the Fellowship and taking an active role in their mission. He would likely propose alternative strategies that involve the use of animals and birds to navigate the treacherous landscapes of Middle-earth. His knowledge of the local flora and fauna would be invaluable, helping the Fellowship to avoid danger and navigate through unfamiliar territories.

Moreover, Radagast's influence over the Corsairs (wild birds of prey and raptors) could prove useful in eliminating Sauron's spies and gathering intelligence. He might also have contributed to the creation of a more harmonious relationship between nature and the Fellowship, reflecting the theme of balance and harmony.

The Impact on the Plot and Characters

Radagast's presence would have a ripple effect on the overall plot of The Lord of the Rings. His knowledge of the animal realm could have helped the Fellowship to make more informed decisions and avoid unexpected obstacles. Additionally, his unwavering loyalty and innocence could have provided a counterbalance to the more cynical and Machiavellian traits of characters like Saruman.

His actions might have also begged the question of why the wise did not utilize the animals more effectively earlier in their journey. Perhaps it was a testament to the underutilization of nature's resources, which might have been a stronger theme in the story had Radagast been more prominent.

Conclusion

While Radagast's direct impact on the Fellowship of the Ring might have been limited, his presence would have added a unique layer to the narrative. His relationship with animals and his role in maintaining the balance of nature suggests that he could have been a valuable asset to the Fellowship, especially in a world where both plant and animal life are under threat.

Had Radagast joined the Fellowship, it would have been a testament to the importance of every character in Middle-earth, regardless of their level of power or prominence.