The Controversy of Qui-Gon's Decision and Anakin's Fate

The classic debate in the Star Wars universe revolves around the question: If Qui-Gon Jinn had lived to become Anakin Skywalker's master, would Anakin have turned to the dark side? The answer, according to numerous discussions and analyses, suggests a paradoxical truth. Qui-Gon's death has been seen as irrelevant to the eventual fate of Anakin, but it also serves as a critical plot point that shapes Obi-Wan's future role in Anakin's life.

The Unique Qualities of Qui-Gon Jinn

Qui-Gon was known for his maturity and decisiveness, in stark contrast to his apprentice, Obi-Wan Kenobi, who excelled in the passive Soresu style. Unlike Obi-Wan, Qui-Gon was deeply passionate about the Republic and actively fought against its enemies. His character development highlights his belief in the Republic and his dedication to the cause of justice.

Before his death, Qui-Gon made significant contributions to the Star Wars universe, such as purchasing the enslaved mother of Anakin Skywalker. He also planned to expose Darth Sidious and Darth Tyranus, significant figures in the plot. These actions were crucial in setting the stage for a potential different outcome for Anakin's destiny.

Qui-Gon's Role in Preventing the Fall of the Republic

Had Qui-Gon lived long enough to become Anakin's master, the course of events could have been drastically altered. Obi-Wan once remarked that Palpatine would have had a much harder time converting Anakin to the dark side. The extended period of training and mentorship under Qui-Gon would have allowed Qui-Gon to provide Anakin with a broader understanding of the Jedi Code and the consequences of the dark side.

Furthermore, Qui-Gon's ability to curb Anakin's anger and guide him toward a better path would have undoubtedly altered the political landscape. The fall of the Republic and the subsequent creation of the Galactic Empire might have been averted, or at the very least, delayed significantly. Qui-Gon's wisdom and experience in managing complex situations would have been invaluable in shaping a more stable and ethical society.

The Irrelevance of Qui-Gon's Death

Despite the potential changes, it is also debated whether Qui-Gon's death was truly irrelevant. Seemingly, his death was a product of his own conflicted views with his mentor Count Dooku. It has been argued that the movies were not strictly made in chronological order, and Obi-Wan's role as Anakin's master was predestined from the beginning. The choice to train Anakin as a Jedi, though controversial, was ultimately the path chosen for a greater narrative purpose.

The decision to train a 9-10-year-old Anakin was indeed a risky move, as he was already deeply attached to his mother. Qui-Gon Jinn would have been more critical than Obi-Wan, which could have led to resentment from Anakin. The concept of Anakin's "fate" to fall to the dark side is well established in the series, though it raises questions about the nature of destiny and predetermined choices.

Reshaping Anakin's Destiny

Some argue that if Qui-Gon had not found Anakin, he might have become a darksider, in which case he would have "risen" to the light side. This idea hinges on the principle of mastering both the light and dark sides of the Force. Qui-Gon's decision to bring Anakin into the Jedi Order was part of a larger narrative that seeks to demonstrate that both sides of the Force can be powerful, and that balance is key.

Ultimately, the fate of Anakin Skywalker is a complex interplay of destiny, personal choices, and the actions of those around him. Qui-Gon Jinn's death, while pivotal, is but one part of a much larger story. The Expanded Universe and fan theories continue to explore these themes, offering new perspectives on the classic characters and their journeys.

In conclusion, if Qui-Gon Jinn had lived to become Anakin's master, the outcome may have been different. However, the irrelevance of his death to Anakin's ultimate fate underscores the multifaceted nature of the Star Wars saga. Qui-Gon's role in shaping the future of the Republic and Anakin's life remains a critical element in understanding the complexity of the Star Wars universe.