Would L. Ron Hubbard's Return SwayScientologists?

Imagine a scenario where L. Ron Hubbard, the controversial founder of Scientology, miraculously returned to life. His first statement to the public would be that Scientology is a joke and to leave it behind if it doesn’t work for you. Would this change the minds of his believers, or would they remain resolute in their beliefs? Let's explore this thought-experiment and others that might arise.

The Case of Henry Ford

If we substitute Henry Ford for L. Ron Hubbard, the situation becomes clearer. Would a reborn Henry Ford, suddenly stating that automobiles are nothing more than toys, make those who depend on them return to using horse-drawn carriages? The answer, of course, is no. These beliefs are entrenched, and the sheer convenience and utility of automobiles are unlikely to be shaken by hypothetical assertions.

Scientology is Not a Matter of 'Belief'

Scientology, unlike many belief systems, is not built on faith. It is a series of practices and techniques designed to improve one's life and mental state. There is no dogma or doctrine to be faithfully adhered to. Rather, it is an empirical process: if it works for you, great; if not, try to figure out why or move on to something else.

Declaring Scientology Dead

Enter Justin Alan Craig, claiming to be Lafayette Ronald Hubbard and the reincarnated L. Ron Hubbard. According to this self-proclaimed successor, Scientology is dead and should be replaced by Esperianism. However, thus far, these claims have not swayed many of Scientology's followers. Church of Scientology spokesperson Karen Pauw dismissed his statements as 'unhinged and ludicrous'.

Reactions and Threats

The publication of Lafayette’s book, which was originally titled 'Scientology Infinity', led to it being removed from Amazon. The book is now called 'Infinity'. The Church of Scientology, however, has not kept silent. They have been known to resort to extreme measures to defend their organization. Were L. Ron Hubbard to return, we might see similar actions, such as auditing and even more drastic actions like threatening to force him to a remote location and questioning his identity to ensure his authenticity.

The Reality of Scientology

L. Ron Hubbard was a science fiction writer with a troubled past and a penchant for self-promotion. His creation, Scientology, thrives on the promise of self-improvement and financial success. Despite its controversial nature, the organization has managed to amass a significant following and has been endorsed by Hollywood celebrities. It is treated as a business in some countries instead of a religion.

The Likely Outcome

Given the nature of Scientology and the character of L. Ron Hubbard, it seems unlikely that such a return would change much. Instead, it might elicit amusement, curiosity, or perhaps a brief period of confusion, but ultimately, the organization and its followers would remain largely intact. L. Ron Hubbard, if he were alive today, might even find the situation amusing, knowing how his legacy has withstood the test of time.