If Harry Potter had the Philosopher's Stone, Whom Would He Give the Resurrection Stone to Escape Death?

It is a well-known fact that the Philosopher's Stone and the Resurrection Stone are two distinct artifacts in the Harry Potter series. While the Philosopher's Stone can grant immortality and extend one's life, the Resurrection Stone can only allow for communication with the dead through a veil. This article delves into the hypothetical scenario of which character Harry Potter would give the Resurrection Stone to if he possessed it.

Philosopher's Stone vs. Resurrection Stone

Philosopher's Stone: In the Harry Potter series, the Philosopher's Stone is a legendary artifact that can provide immortality. It saves a person from death by enabling them to live infinitely. The Philosopher's Stone is a central object in "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone" (referred to as "Goblet of Fire" in your original text).

Resurrection Stone: The Resurrection Stone, one of the Deathly Hallows, allows its owner to communicate with the spirits of the deceased. It is only capable of showing those who have passed away and does not grant literal resurrection or bring people back from the dead. The Resurrection Stone is a significant artifact in the series, particularly in "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows."

Harry Potter's Choices Based on the Timeline

Case 1: Before Goblet of Fire

If Harry Potter had the Philosopher's Stone before the Goblet of Fire, he might have given it to Sirius Black. Sirius was a wanted criminal in the wizarding world and was under attack by the Ministry of Magic. The Philosopher's Stone could have potentially protected Sirius, allowing him to live in safety. Furthermore, Sirius had a strong bond with Harry and would likely have appreciated the protection that the Philosopher's Stone could offer.

Case 2: Between Goblet of Fire and Deathly Hallows

If Harry had the Philosopher's Stone after the Goblet of Fire but before the Deathly Hallows, he would likely keep it with himself. The Philosopher's Stone is a highly sought-after object, and it would be strategically unwise to give it to someone else at this stage of the series. The conflict with Voldemort was intensifying, and the Philosopher's Stone could potentially be used to protect Harry and his allies from a powerful source of life extension.

Case 3: At the Start of Deathly Hallows

At the start of the Deathly Hallows, if Harry had the Philosopher's Stone, he might have given it to Remus Lupin or Severus Snape, depending on his knowledge of Snape's true allegiance. If Harry knew from the beginning that Snape was actually on his side, he may have trusted Snape with the Philosopher's Stone. Additionally, Remus Lupin, a trusted and wise ally, could have been a sensible choice. The Philosopher's Stone could have provided a form of defense and survival, particularly when confronted with the Dark Arts and Voldemort's horcruxes.

Harry Potter's Likely Choice

Overall, Harry Potter is most likely to give the Philosopher's Stone to Sirius Black if he had it before the Goblet of Fire. Sirius Black was a beloved and loyal friend to Harry's family, and his protection would have been a significant priority for Harry. Sirius would have understood the value of protecting his loved ones and would have used the Philosopher's Stone for its intended purpose, which is to extend life and keep one safe from the darker forces at play.

In the complex world of Harry Potter, the Philosopher's Stone is a powerful object, but it also presents moral and strategic challenges. Harry's choices would be influenced by the current situation, the characters' loyalties, and the immediate threats he faced. His desire to protect those he loves and his resilience in the face of danger make Sirius Black the most likely recipient for the Philosopher's Stone in this scenario.