What Would Happen If Brynden Tully (Blackfish) Led the Riverlands in A Clash of Kings?

In the realm of George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire, the strategic brilliance or strategic missteps of influential figures can drastically alter the course of war and political alliances. If Brynden Tully, also known as the Blackfish, had assumed command of the Riverlands military instead of his nephew Edmure Tully, several key factors could have shifted dramatically, potentially leading to significant changes in the War of the Five Kings.

Role of Brynden Tully in the Riverlands Military

Brynden Tully was renowned for his combat experience and military acumen. His talents in warfare and leadership were not only learned through his participation in numerous battles but also honed through the unique circumstances of his life, including his years of being a captive in a tower.

His strategic decisions and tactical agility would likely have been more effective compared to Edmure's tendency towards cautious and often misinformed actions. Given the turbulent nature of the Riverlands, characterized by its rivers and strategic locations, Brynden's experience could have led to the utilization of guerrilla tactics and a more adaptive defensive strategy.

Defensive Strategy and Geography

Utilizing the unique geographical features of the Riverlands, Brynden would almost certainly have chosen a defensive posture. The network of rivers and marshes provided natural barriers and strategic chokepoints, which could have been fortified to maximum effect. This approach would have mitigated the risk of heavy losses and exploitable vulnerabilities that characterized the Riverlands under Edmure's command.

Enhanced Diplomatic and Alliances

Brynden Tully was known for his political savvy and pragmatic approach. In contrast to his nephew's naivety, Brynden would have been more adept at forming and maintaining alliances. The Blackfish might have sought to strengthen connections with other local lords such as the Freys or even negotiated with the Lannisters to buy time and stabilize the region, reducing the likelihood of drastic actions like the one-sided massacre at the Red Wedding.

Impact on Troop Morale and Leadership

Under Brynden's command, troop morale and leadership would have significantly improved. His decisiveness and sense of duty would have inspired greater loyalty and determination among soldiers. As a recognized fierce warrior and respected commander, Brynden's leadership style would have instilled confidence and resilience, ensuring that soldiers fought harder and had higher motivations to achieve victory.

Key Battles and Outcomes

Several key battles and interactions under Brynden's command could have turned out differently. For instance, holding Riverrun against a powerful Lannister assault might have been more feasible, potentially delaying significant losses and setting a different precedent for resistance against the invading forces. This could have altered the overall timeline of the War of the Five Kings.

Long-Term Impact on the War

With a more competent commander in the Riverlands, the war itself might have been prolonged and the balance of power shifted. The ability of House Tully to control and defend the Riverlands for a more extended period could have weakened the resources and influence of the Lannisters. This shift could have led to different alliances and outcomes in the later stages of the conflict, potentially altering the story's ultimate resolution.

In conclusion, the hypothetical scenario of Brynden Tully leading the Riverlands in A Clash of Kings would have likely resulted in more effective military strategies, an improvement in troop morale, and possibly a significantly altered course of the War of the Five Kings.