Identifying the Best Warrior among the Feudal Lords of Westeros

The world of Westeros is filled with powerful and skilled warriors, each with their own unique abilities and histories. In this article, we will analyze and compare several prominent figures, including Brynden Tully, Blackfish, Rickard Karstark, Smalljon Umber, Yohn Royce, Jeor Mormont, Alliser Thorne, Jeor Mormont, Randyll Tarly, Tywin Lannister, and Mace Tyrell, to determine who the best warrior is among this formidable group.

Evaluating the Leaders

From the Books and screenings, it is clear that Jeor Mormont and Mace Tyrell are wise and capable leaders. However, their strategic prowess does not necessarily equate to being great warriors. The same can be said for Smalljon Umber and Yohn Royce. Though Rickard Karstark is handy with a sword, his age and fighting style do not make him a great warrior either.

Comparing the Warriors: Blackfish and Alliser Thorne

In my opinion, Blackfish and Alliser Thorne would be about equal in terms of swordsmanship and the ability to read opponents. Both of these lords are well-regarded fighters, making them formidable contenders in the realm of Westerosi warriors.

Determining the Champion: Randyll Tarly

By a process of elimination, it is clear that the best warrior among this list is Randyll Tarly. A significant advantage for Tarly is his possession of Heartsbane, a Valyrian steel sword. Unlike the other warriors on our list, Tarly has been shown to have a strong one-on-one combat skill, making him the top contender in this group.

Conclusion: Brynden Tully as the Runner-Up

In the specific list provided, my pick for the best warrior is Randyll Tarly. If we were to choose a second best warrior, it would be Brynden Tully. Brynden Tully, also known as Blackfish, is a well-known fighter with a reputation for his tenacious and skilled combat.

The evaluation of these warriors is based on multiple factors including their combat skills, leadership qualities, and experiences. While some are better leaders, others are more accomplished in one-on-one combat, making the decision a complex but intriguing discussion in the Westerosi world.