How Jean-Luc Picard Would Handle First Contact with The Dominion in Star Trek: The Next Generation

In the vast universe of Star Trek, the creative franchise presents numerous challenges and opportunities for its iconic characters. One such scenario is the hypothetical first contact between Jean-Luc Picard and The Dominion. Given his diplomatic skills and strategic mindset, how would Captain Picard approach such a monumental and potentially dangerous situation?

Conviction by Example

Based on Picard's proven track record in Star Trek: The Next Generation, he would likely begin by establishing a principle of mutual respect and shared sovereignty. This would involve inviting the Dominion's representative to his ship, thus demonstrating that the Federation values open and transparent communication. By inviting their representative aboard, Picard would initiate a process that respects their sovereignty and ensures that any future relationship is not forced upon them.

Through this gesture, Picard would lay the groundwork for further dialogue, emphasizing that any dealings with the Federation would be done with the consent and goodwill of the Dominion. This approach aligns with his philosophy of peace and understanding, reflecting his belief that strength lies in cooperation rather than conflict.

Strategic Mutual Benefit

In addition to diplomatic assurances, Picard would propose strategic collaborations that would be mutually beneficial. For instance, he might alert the Dominion to the dangers posed by the Borg, a threat that the Dominion could neither ignore nor afford to mishandle. By doing so, he would emphasize the Federation's value as a partner in maintaining galactic security.

To further cement this relationship, Picard would recommend the establishment of outposts on both sides of the wormhole. The Dominion's outpost would be built within their own territory, ensuring it is more in line with their interests and needs. On the Federation side, Deep Space Nine (DS9) could be enhanced into a better monitoring and defense post. This enhancement would not only improve the overall security but also create a new opportunity for cooperation and shared intelligence.

Personnel Changes for Better Relationships

In his approach to DS9, Picard would advocate for significant personnel changes. He would suggest replacing the volatile and troubled Captain Benjamin Sisko, who had a stormy relationship with the Bajorans and their Prophets. Instead, he would propose a commander who could focus on special relationships and better interstellar diplomacy. This shift would not only strengthen alliances but also pave the way for a smoother relationship between the Federation and the Bajorans, a key ally in their galactic endeavors.

Alternative Scenarios and Worst-Case Measures

However, if the initial diplomatic efforts fail to convince the Dominion that the Federation does not pose a threat, Picard would take decisive action. In such a scenario, he would close the wormhole for good. This measure would serve to protect the Federation from any unwanted or potentially hostile contact with the Dominion, aligning with Jonathan Fate's advice in a later episode eventually taken by the later Sisko. Closing the wormhole would create a physical and symbolic barrier, preventing any further contact until a more amenable situation arises.

Conclusion

Through his diplomatic prowess, strategic thinking, and unwavering commitment to mutual respect and cooperation, Jean-Luc Picard would approach the first contact with The Dominion with a clear and comprehensive plan. His actions would not only reflect his character traits but also set a foundation for a potentially prosperous and peaceful relationship. Whether through convincing demonstrations or decisive measures, Picard's approach would underscore the Federation's commitment to open dialogue and mutual understanding in a universe complex and diverse as Star Trek's.