Horror in Fiction: Is It a Step Too Far or Just Far Enough?

Is the horror genre pushing the moral boundaries too far? This debate often revolves around the concept of what just right means for different individuals. Each person has their own threshold of what they find too far or not far enough, much like the Goldilocks situation where one might find some porridge too hot and others too cold.

Moral Fluff and Aristotelian Perspective

The horror genre is often seen as a form of moral fluff, especially when we consider the extent to which it explores the darkest aspects of the human psyche. In my opinion, the genre is predominantly fluff, but this doesn't render it meaningless or without value.

When we analyze the role of horror in art, we can look to Aristotle for insights. Although Aristotle did not specifically speak about horror, he did address tragedy, delving into themes of incest, murder, and offering a form of catharsis to the audience. His view on tragedy suggests that engaging with dark and fearful scenarios can be beneficial. The Italian translation of Aristotle's theory on tragedy mentions the purification and purgation of emotions—particularly pity and fear—through art.

Art as Expression

Any movie or book is a form of art, and art is a reflection of the human mind. The human mind can naturally harbor dark thoughts and emotions, and trying to censor those parts might not bring us closer to any form of moral superiority.

Exploring scary scenarios, particularly through fiction, allows us to confront and process our deepest fears in a safe and controlled environment. This can be a therapeutic and cathartic experience. Horror movies often present scenarios that we find ridiculous when discussed with friends, thereby debunking the things that haunt our nightmares and keeping them in the realm of entertainment rather than reality.

Art and Authenticity

Is it right to simply tear out the less appealing aspects of life and pretend everything is perfect? The horror genre, with its often exaggerated and unrealistic nature, invites us to engage with these fears and, in doing so, encourages a form of authenticity.

Some people find value in these stories, driven by curiosity or a desire to understand the darker side of human experience. Others, like the ones who might enjoy the Human Centipede for its sheer oddity, find a form of entertainment in the bizarre.

Ultimately, the value of horror lies in its ability to provide a platform for exploration, catharsis, and sometimes even laughter. While it may not be for everyone, the genre serves an important role in our cultural landscape by delving into the darker aspects of human nature without crossing a line that precludes all value.

Conclusion

Is horror a step too far? Perhaps, depending on individual perspectives. However, it can also be a necessary exploration of the darker facets of human psychology, offering both catharsis and a therapeutic means to confront our fears.