Hierarchy Succession in Westeros: What if Aegon IV’s Bastards Lack Legitimization and Daeron II Dies Un-crowned?

Westeros, a vast continent in HBO’s Game of Thrones, has a complex feudal society centered around the throne and its succession. The question arises, who would have been the next in line to become its ruler if Aegon IV never legitimized his bastards, and Daeron II died before he could be crowned king? Let's explore this intricate web of royal lineage and potential rulers.

The Current Order: Aegon IV’s Sons and Daenerys

Before we delve into the hypothetical scenarios, let's first establish the current order of succession based on the known royal history:

Aegon IV Targaryen (171 AC-184 AC) had several children, but Aegon's youngest son, Baelor, was sent to the Wall. Daeron II Targaryen (184 AC-196 AC) survived Aegon IV and had four sons: Aerys II Targaryen (196 AC-299 AC), Rhaegar Targaryen (232 AC-299 AC), Rhaella Targaryen (born around 234 AC), and Maekar I Targaryen (259 AC-299 AC).

Scenarios If Aegon IV’s Bastards Are Unlegitimized

Given Aegon IV's illegitimate sons who were never given official status, what would the lineup be if they were not included in the succession?

Aerys II Targaryen: As the oldest surviving son and heir, Aerys II would have taken the throne. This scenario is straightforward and aligns with the established order of succession as known in Westeros. Rhaegar Targaryen: If Aerys II had predeceased him, Rhaegar would have been the next in line. However, this is not a direct outcome of the hypothetical scenario given that Rhaegar died in 299 AC under controversial circumstances. Rhaella Targaryen: While a potential heir, Rhaella's position in the line of succession could be questionable as her coronation would likely depend on the political climate and the prevailing laws of succession. Maekar I Targaryen: As the heir after Rhaella, Maekar would have taken the throne. However, this would be a significant shift from the current narrative and would lead to substantial political upheaval. Maekar's rule is well-documented, but his elevation to the throne thus early would create a new timeline.

Challenging the Conventional Succession: Daenerys as a Contender

What if the absence of Aegon IV's illegitimate sons opened up the field for other claimants? Consider the possibility of Daenerys Targaryen taking the throne. Just as she did in the Essos storyline, Daenerys Targaryen could bridge the two main Targaryen lines:

Aegon III Targaryen: Daenerys could marry Daemon Targaryen, a popular and influential figure who holds significant support among the Dornish and Lannister factions. This marriage would consolidate the two major branches. Viserys II Targaryen: Daenerys’ marriage would secure her legitimacy by marrying into the main line of succession, ensuring her claim to the throne is recognized.

However, this scenario requires navigating a series of complex political and social challenges. It would involve ensuring the acceptance of a non-biological ruler, managing alliances, and addressing the broader factions that vie for power in Westeros.

Conclusion: A Shift in Targaryen Lineage

The hypothetical scenarios presented here illustrate the intricate dynamics and potential shifts in Westerosi succession. Whether through legitimate means or unconventional alliances, the Targaryen lineage and the throne remain a central focus of political intrigue. Each potential heir brings unique challenges and advantages, shaping the future of Westeros in ways unforeseen by even the most astute of courtiers.