Gone With The Wind: The Unconditional End of Scarlett and Rhett’s Love
Gone With The Wind: The Unconditional End of Scarlett and Rhett’s Love
Gone With The Wind, written by Margaret Mitchell and published in 1936, is a classic novel that captures the tumultuous love story of Scarlett O'Hara and Rhett Butler. Many readers and movie-goers believe that the two reunite after the Civil War, but the truth, as revealed in the book, is far more poignant.
Scarlett's Pursuit and Rhett's Anger
More often than not, viewers of the 1939 film adaptation leave with the impression that Scarlett and Rhett get back together. However, the novel paints a very different picture. Margaret Mitchell, in her writings, made it clear that her intention was to demonstrate that certain things, particularly broken relationships, cannot be fixed or made amends for.
Scarlet's Neglect and Rhett's Indifference
Acting on this intent, the novel emphasizes the depth of Rhett's disillusionment and eventual detachment from Scarlett. After Scarlett's miscarriage and subsequent long illness, Rhett loses interest in her particularly when she does not call for him, despite his initial hurt and anger. Ironically, this is when Scarlett starts to care for him, albeit fearfully.
Further complicating matters, after the tragic death of their daughter Bonnie, Scarlett becomes particularly cruel to Rhett, accusing him of causing Bonnie's death. The novel suggests that several years pass during this period, highlighting the strength of Rhett's resolve to put an end to their relationship.
Final Farewell
By the time of their last conversation, Rhett is emotionally distant, as evidenced by the line, “I wish I could care where you go or what you do but I can’t.” In the movie, Rhett says “I don’t give a damn,” which is often interpreted as anger, but in the novel, the sentiment portrayed is one of sadness and emotional detachment.
The novel demonstrates that even though Scarlett might want to revive Rhett's feelings, a reunion seems unlikely. The impact of her actions and words have taken a toll on them both, and as the book progresses, Rhett drifts further away from Scarlett, both emotionally and physically.
Aftermath and Reflection
After the Civil War, the story explores the aftermath of Scarlett and Rhett’s relationship. As Scarlett experiences the pains of life and the weight of her actions, Rhett continues to withdraw, both from her and from the world around him. His health deteriorates, and he reflects on the time they shared, though the relationship has changed forever.
Scarlett, realizing her mistake, would likely nurse Rhett back to health and beg him for another child. It is a heartbreaking moment, as both characters struggle to find meaning in their lives beyond their love.
Ultimately, the novel concludes with Rhett leaving Scarlett behind, having "had his fun" and now recognizing the futility of their past relationship. Margaret Mitchell wanted readers to understand the true costs of their choices and the impossibility of undoing the damage done.
Concluding Thoughts
Though the movie leaves viewers with the hope that Scarlett and Rhett might reunite, the novel clearly depicts a more somber and definitive end to their love. For those who seek answers and closure, the book offers a powerful reminder of the complexities of human relationships and the enduring impact of our actions.
For fans of Gone With The Wind, it is essential to revisit the book and understand the depth of Margaret Mitchell's narrative. The unconditional end of Scarlett and Rhett's love story is a testament to the novel's enduring power and the timeless themes it explores.