Do You Believe the Rumor That George Lucas Wants to Return and Save Star Wars?

This rumor has been swirling around for some time now, and just like the last time, I highly doubt it. After all, George Lucas probably regrets selling the franchise and watching Disney mess it up. But he should have known better. This crypto-cynicism serves as a reminder that George Lucas has well-established his limitations in the realm of modern blockbuster filmmaking. The truth is, he should not hold any clout in the decisions made for the Star Wars franchise, as it now belongs to Disney.

The Irrelevance of George Lucas' Wishes

The property is owned by Disney, and as such, they will decide what the future of Star Wars looks like. This decision-making process is independent of George Lucas' wishes. What is being 'saved,' anyway? From toxic fan writing and subpar acting, Disney has already demonstrated its ability to produce better content with their own interpretations. The final film before the current phase, The Rise of Skywalker, was widely considered to be more successful than the prequels, despite Lucas' own input. The idea that the last movies would have been better under Lucas' direction is a notion that fans find difficult to justify.

Lucas’ Past Behavior and Intentions

During the production of The Force Awakens, Lucas showed a desire to meddle, often acting in a manner that could only be described as "only I get to ruin my baby!". For instance, he entertained ideas like an Episode VII being a Fantastic Voyage-esque endeavor where shrunken-down heroes could meet and help Midichlorians. This kind of intervention into the creative process is a far cry from the control and respect authors typically yield. Therefore, it is more likely that if George Lucas does indeed want to 'save' Star Wars, it would be in a way that would reek of his overbearing and outdated style.

The Reality of George Lucas' Past Decisions

Luke Skywalker, it seems, is fated to face more significant challenges than just a lack of fan goodwill. Remember, the man behind the scripts of The Phantom Menace, Attack of the Clones, and who created Jar-Jar Binks, is also famous for admitting that the fans would not like the ideas he had for Episodes 7-9. This history raises questions about the feasibility of Lucas' saving the franchise in the way that fans hope. For all the nostalgia and the desire for a return to the formative years of the Star Wars saga, the reality is that Lucas' input might not necessarily lead to the best outcomes.

It's clear that the dreams of fans to see a return to Lucas' creative control are largely rooted in wishful thinking. While there is a natural and understandable attachment to the franchise's origins, it is essential to recognize that the proprietary nature of the franchise and the evolving tastes of audiences have shifted significantly since Lucas’ last influences.

For those interested in the future direction of the Star Wars saga, it's best to look to the developmental and creative teams at Disney and Lucasfilm. The past teaches us that while emotional attachment is strong, practical considerations often guide the course of franchise development.

Ultimately, the future of Star Wars is in the capable hands of those who are dedicated to its continued success, whether or not George Lucas is involved. The franchise has already seen many transformations, and it will continue to evolve in ways that both honor its legacy and address the ever-changing landscape of the film industry.