What are Some Frequently Asked Questions About Movie Critics and Criticism?

Movie critics play a significant role in shaping public opinion about films, but they face numerous questions from the audience. To address some of these common queries, this article highlights the implications of critic biases, the truth behind such biases, and the unique perspectives that different critics offer.

Are Critics Biased Against or For Particular Filmmakers, Directors, or Actors?

A common question people ask is whether critics have inherent biases for or against certain filmmakers, directors, or actors. This often leads to intriguing stories and controversies. For example, consider Pauline Kael, one of the most renowned and influential film critics of the 20th century.

Pauline Kael's relationship with Warren Beatty is a prime example of critic bias. Kael admired Beatty's work for years, even befriending him and integrating him into her circle as a writer. However, after Beatty hired her to write movie scripts, Kael realized that this was a calculated move to prevent her from reviewing his films. As revealed in Peter Biskind’s biography of Warren Beatty, Beatty had orchestrated a misleading situation to manipulate Kael. Upon uncovering this truth, Kael returned to her critical work, giving nothing but negative reviews to all of Beatty's films.

Is There a Critic Who Hates Sci-Fi and Horror Movies?

Another common question that arises is whether a critic can have a personal dislike for certain genres, such as sci-fi and horror movies. Obviously, critics are human beings with their own preferences, which may influence their critical perspectives.

Sheila Benson of the L.A. Times is a case in point. Sheila Benson admitted to hating sci-fi and horror movies, yet she still wrote reviews of them. While her personal taste may affect her critical judgment, it is a testament to the professionalism and dedication of critics in maintaining an unbiased and informed critique. Despite her distaste for these genres, she put in the effort to understand and analyze them, making her reviews more credible and valuable to readers.

Addressing the Impact of Bias

Bias in movie criticism can have significant effects on both the filmmaker and the audience. While some critics may have personal attachments or dislikes, it's essential to recognize that the best critics strive for objectivity and provide a well-rounded, thought-provoking analysis. Critics should be seen as guides who help us better understand and appreciate the films they review.

Addressing questions of bias is important not only for the credibility of the critic but also for the authenticity of film criticism itself. It is the responsibility of both critics and audiences to consider and question these biases in order to foster a more informed and diverse discussion about cinema.

Conclusion

Movie critics face numerous challenges and biases in their work. The examples provided above illustrate the complexity of the critic's role and the impact of personal preferences on critical judgments. By understanding the dynamics of critic bias, we can appreciate the valuable work that critics do and engage in more meaningful discussions about cinema.

Whether Pauline Kael's bias against Warren Beatty's films or Sheila Benson's distaste for sci-fi and horror movies, these stories emphasize the importance of critical objectivity and the human connection in film criticism.