Free to Choose: Arya Stark's Journey in A Song of Ice and Fire

In George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire series, Arya Stark is faced with complex choices and moral dilemmas that shape her journey from a defiant young girl into a formidable assassin. When considering the scenario of Arya Stark abandoning the Faceless Men, it is crucial to understand the dynamic between her and her mentors, as well as the potential consequences such a departure could bring.

The Faceless Men and Their Influence

The Faceless Men, agents of the nameless god and members of the mysterious House of the Black and White, are known for their brutal and ruthless nature. They have a strict adherence to their beliefs and practices, and breaking their rules can have severe repercussions. In the event that Arya were to abandon them, the Faceless Men would likely not take her departure lightly. They may view her leaving as a betrayal, given the intense training and loyalty they demand.

Agency and Choice

Despite the strong influence of the Faceless Men over Arya, she retains a degree of agency. Her journey is about reclaiming her identity and deciding what aspects of her training and the Faceless Men's philosophy she wishes to embrace or reject. Arya has demonstrated her independent thinking and desire for control, which allows her to make these crucial decisions for herself.

Risks and Consequences

If Arya were to abandon the Faceless Men, there might be immediate attempts by her former mentors to retaliate. The events in A Feast for Crows highlight the serious consequences she faces, such as the assassination attempt. Following her decision to kill Dareon, Arya surrenders her sight. However, the Faceless Men still allow her to continue her training, suggesting that she may have earned their trust.

The Wind of Winter and the Events in Braavos

In The Wind of Winter, GRRM provides insights into Arya's experiences in Braavos. When Ser Harrods Swyft arrives in Braavos on a mission to negotiate with the Iron Bank, Arya observes the performative play The Bloody Hand. Her interactions with one of Ser Harrods' guards, Raff, reveal the dangers and potential conflicts she faces. By seducing and later stabbing him, Arya demonstrates her willingness to take risks and the profound impact of her actions.

Conclusion and Reflection

While the Faceless Men may attempt to retaliate if Arya were to leave, she has the choice to abandon them. They have provided her with numerous opportunities and have shown a willingness to allow her to continue under their guidance. The reasons for this include her unique abilities and the bond formed through her bravery, such as saving Jaqen H'gar's life, which suggests a level of trust and respect between them.

Arya Stark's journey in A Song of Ice and Fire is a testament to her unwavering determination and unyielding spirit. As she makes key choices and faces significant challenges, her story continues to unfold, captivating readers with its depth and complexity.