Theon Greyjoy's Future: Who Would Foster Him if Ned Stark Refused?

The Greyjoy Rebellion marked a significant turn in the history of the Seven Kingdoms, and the aftermath brought about questions regarding the future of House Greyjoy. One critical decision was the fostering of Theon Greyjoy by Lord Ned Stark. Who would have taken up this mantle if Ned Stark refused to do so?

The Role of Ned Stark

Ned Stark was chosen for a specific reason: his kinship with the North and his inherent sense of honor. His close relation to the North meant he could ensure Theon would bring honor and respect to the Iron Islands, while also serving as a safeguard against any future attacks by the Ironborn.

If Ned Stark were to refuse the task, other prominent figures would have had to step in. One possible candidate would be Tywin Lannister. Tywin’s strong leadership and reputation for loyalty to the throne would make him an ideal choice. His strong stance on the importance of honor and the monarchy would resonate with Theon. Additionally, Tywin’s influence in King’s Landing would position him to instill the right values and expectations in Theon.

Robert Baratheon: Robert's Kingsm Hilton

Robert Baratheon, the newly crowned King, could have also taken on the responsibility of fostering Theon. As the King, he would naturally be concerned about maintaining the loyalty and stability of all Houses in the realm. By taking Theon to Kings Landing as a page, Robert could ensure Theon receives the royal upbringing necessary to understand his position and responsibilities as a noble. This would also symbolize the King’s commitment to the Iron Islands and their future within the realm.

Stannis Baratheon: A Dire Option

Stannis Baratheon, with his reputation for pragmatism and unwavering loyalty, would also have been a viable option. His fostering of Theon would still be a testament to his loyalty to the throne. However, Stannis’s reputation might have frightened Balon Greyjoy even more, as he is known for his meticulous planning and readiness to use others for his goals.

Conclusion

The fostering of Theon Greyjoy post-Greyjoy Rebellion was a strategic decision that aimed to ensure the future loyalty and capability of the Iron-born. If Ned Stark had refused, the role would have likely fallen to Tywin Lannister, Robert Baratheon, or Stannis Baratheon. Each of these choices had its merits, with Tywin’s strong leadership and loyalty to the throne being particularly compelling for the role.