Fault and Responsibility in 'A Quiet Place': Mother, Father, or the Daughter?

The 2018 horror film A Quiet Place presents a chilling exploration of survival, communication, and the profound weight of responsibility. As audiences leave the theater, many are quick to assign blame to the parents for the brutal deaths of their son. However, a closer examination of the plot reveals that the daughter, for her reckless actions, shoulders a significant share of the blame. This essay delves into the multifaceted roles of the mother, father, and their deaf teenage daughter, and argues that the daughter was both foolish and selfish in her choices, ultimately costing her brother and her father their lives.

Introduction

A Quiet Place is a poignant and terrifying tale of a family’s struggle to survive after an alien invasion that has left people vulnerable to the sound of their own voices. The film tells the story of the Abbott family—which includes a deaf daughter, a single mother, and a father—living in a world where the slightest noise can be fatal. The movie is a masterclass in tension and suspense, and yet, it leaves viewers questioning the right and wrong of the family's actions.

The Mother's Role

The mother, Evelyn Abbott, has a formidable role in the survival drama. Her close relationship with her deaf daughter, Marcus, and her responsiveness to the precarious environment she and her family find themselves in are commendable. Throughout the film, she shows unwavering determination, both in training her children to be silent and in ensuring their safety. However, there are moments when she could be criticized for overprotectiveness and strictness, which might be a factor reflecting her heightened anxiety.

For example, Evelyn's decision to discipline Marcus with the use of a pillow in a moment of panic could be seen as an exertion of control that exceeded the situation's merit. This might have contributed to Marcus's rebellion and the adverse effects of that rebellion. Overall, while the mother’s actions were driven by a deep-seated protective instinct, they were not entirely without fault.

The Father's Role

The father, Trevor Abbott, appears to be the most willing participant in the strategy of maintaining silence. Unlike the mother, he shows neither fear nor anger and instead approaches the survival issue with a level-headedness that is commendable. Trevor's intelligence and ingenuity are put to good use, helping the family devise clever strategies to avoid detection by the creatures. However, his downplaying of the situation and his reluctance to involve the police might be seen as insufficient. He could be argued to have failed to fully grasp the gravity of the threat and not take necessary precautions.

The father's character development shows a certain amount of character or plot weakness, failing to weave more dynamic character arcs, making the portrayal somewhat flat. Nonetheless, Trevor's role in the family's survival is complex and multifaceted, with neither full neglect nor complete adequacy. He remains a critical figure in the family's survival strategy but his approach, at times, could be criticized for being somewhat risky in its simplicity.

The Daughter's Actions and Reactions: The Real Culprit

The daughter, Marcus, is arguably the most misguided and reckless character in the film. Despite being deaf, her actions are driven by a lack of empathy and a stubborn refusal to follow the rules set by her parents. Her actions are not excusable and directly lead to the deaths of her brother and father. The deaf girl provided her little brother a loud battery-operated toy, knowing the dangers of such actions. This defiance and willfulness reveal a significant disregard for the rules that the family has painstakingly established.

Marcus's selfishness and reckless behavior are epitomized in her handling of the toy, which contradicts all the training she had received. She shows a complete lack of understanding of the severe danger she poses to her family. This act is emblematic of her defiance and refusal to heed her parents' warnings. Her actions were a turning point in the film, leading to an irreversible tragedy that could have been averted if she had heeded the family's rules.

Conclusion

The characters in A Quiet Place are complex, each with their own strengths and weaknesses. While the mother and father bear some responsibility for their actions during the survival ordeal, the real blame lies with the deaf daughter. Her foolishness and selfish actions are what ultimately cause the death of her brother and father, highlighting the consequences of defying the norms and rules set for survival in a dangerous world. The movie serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of rebellion and the importance of following community and family rules.

Furthermore, A Quiet Place prompts us to consider the psychological and emotional impacts of living in a high-stakes survival situation, where every decision can result in life or death. The film raises important questions about the role of communication, trust, and the balance between love and understanding. In the end, it is the daughter's actions that should be the focus of blame, as her reckless behavior directly led to tragedy, while the parents were doing their best to protect their family.

Keywords

A Quiet Place parental responsibility deaf daughter movie analysis blame