Introduction

Since the release of the film series, The Hobbit, fans have been divided on the idea of a possible romance between Thorin Oakenshield and Tauriel. This essay explores the various perspectives and sentiments that fans have expressed regarding this pair, drawing insights from both critically acclaimed reviews and the thoughts of the audience.

Support for the Romance

Some fans embraced the notion of a romance between Thorin and Tauriel. They argued that such a relationship would add a layer of depth to Thorin, showcasing his vulnerabilities while providing a counterbalance to his stoic nature. Tauriel, as a strong female character, would humanize Thorin and potentially help viewers understand his journey on a more personal level.

Criticism of Canon Divergence

At the same time, many fans criticized the introduction of a romantic subplot that was not present in J.R.R. Tolkien's original works. They felt that the storyline detracted from the established lore and character arcs, particularly Thorin's quest for the Arkenstone and the reclaiming of Erebor. This perspective highlights the importance of maintaining faithfulness to the source material.

Tauriel's Role

There was a divide among viewers regarding Tauriel's character. Some appreciated her as a strong female character who could hold her own in the male-dominated narrative. Others believed her presence was mainly for the sake of adding a romantic subplot, which they considered unnecessary. The portrayal of Tauriel in the film series has sparked both admiration and criticism.

Chemistry and Execution

Fans who supported the romance often praised the chemistry between Thorin (portrayed by Richard Armitage) and Tauriel (portrayed by Evangeline Lilly). However, others felt that the romance felt rushed or underdeveloped, leading to a lack of emotional investment. The execution of the romance, including the pacing and development of the relationship, became a central point of discussion among viewers.

Impact on Fan Culture

The potential romance between Thorin and Tauriel has also had a significant impact on fan culture. Fans have created a substantial amount of fan fiction and fan art, often exploring the dynamics between the two characters in greater detail than the films present. This creative output allows fans to explore nuanced relationships that go beyond the film's boundaries, adding new dimensions to the characters and their interactions.

Conclusion

The reactions to a possible romance between Thorin Oakenshield and Tauriel in The Hobbit trilogy were diverse, reflecting a range of opinions on character development, fidelity to the source material, and the effectiveness of the film adaptations. Whether supported or criticized, the introduction of this romantic subplot has certainly left a lasting impact on the fan community and the characters themselves.