Failure in BUD/S Training: Options for Those Who Didn't Make It

Navy SEAL training, known as BUD/S (Basic Underwater Demolition/Seal), is notoriously demanding and intense. Many individuals who enter the program fail to meet the rigorous standards and are subsequently deemed unfit for continued training. What happens to these individuals? Do they return to regular duty or are they out of luck for good after failing once? This article explores the various options available to those who don't make it through BUD/S training.

Return to Regular Duty

While the initial failure in BUD/S can be disheartening, it doesn’t necessarily mean the end of one’s military career. In some cases, individuals who fail BUD/S training can return to regular duty. This is particularly true if an injury was the cause of the failure and the person demonstrated a prior capability before the setback. If this is the case, the individual may be given the opportunity to reapply for a later class after medical clearance and a renewed commitment to training.

Reapplication Process After Injuries

The process of reapplying for BUD/S training after an injury involves several steps. Firstly, the injured individual needs to recover fully and regain the necessary physical fitness and mental resilience. Once the recovery period is complete, the individual must inform the appropriate authorities about their desire to reapply. They will need to submit a formal request, detailing their past performance and the reasons for the initial failure. This paperwork must be thoroughly reviewed and approved by the relevant command before the individual can be considered for a reapplication.

Coaching and Retraining for Success

For those who are aware of the reasons for their initial failure, further coaching and retraining can significantly improve their chances of success in future attempts. The Marine Brought to the Point program, for example, is designed for service members who have failed combat training programs, including BUD/S. This program focuses on reconditioning individuals physically and mentally, and provides them with the resources and support needed to overcome their challenges.

Not Automatically Discharged

Contrary to popular belief, failing BUD/S training does not automatically mean a discharge from the Navy. If the individual chooses not to reapply for BUD/S training, they can still train for another rating. This transition allows them to explore other career paths within the Navy, depending on their skills and qualifications. While this route may not lead to becoming a Navy SEAL, it offers the opportunity to excel in other specialized roles and contribute to the military in meaningful ways. Some individuals may not initially consider their failure a setback, but rather an opportunity to reassess their career goals and find a new path within the Navy.

Common Misconceptions

Several misconceptions surround the outcome of failing BUD/S training. For instance, a Navy recruiter might appeal to a potential enlistee using enticing promises of financial bonuses and attractive assignments in the Nuclear Power Program. While the military does offer financial incentives and different career paths, it’s crucial to be aware of the challenges and the reality of the situation. Recruiters often highlight the potential rewards while downplaying the difficulties and the reality that, for some, a failed attempt at BUD/S leads to a different but rewarding career in the Navy.

Unrated Sailors and Ratings

Unrated sailors, often referred to as the “bitches” of the ship, are those who have not been assigned a specific rating. They typically handle the most mundane and unpleasant tasks on board. Despite their reputation, these sailors can still achieve promotions and career advancement, albeit at a slower pace. Moreover, they may have the opportunity to join a different rating or pursue specialized training programs that align with their interests and skills. It’s important to note that while the immediate designation as an unrated sailor might be demoralizing, it doesn’t mark the end of one’s military career or progression.

Conclusion

While BUD/S training is challenging and competitive, it’s crucial to understand the various options available for those who fail. Whether it's returning to regular duty, reapplying with a fresh perspective, or exploring other career paths within the Navy, there are avenues for individuals to continue serving and contributing to the military community. The failed attempt at BUD/S training might be a significant hurdle, but it does not necessarily define one’s future in the Navy.