Exploring the Mysteries of 'Game of Thrones': Why Couldn't Arya Simply Ask Bran What?

Game of Thrones, known for its intricate plots and deep character development, often challenges viewers with complex thematic elements. One episode that sparked a lot of discussion was S08 E06. Many fans wondered, why couldn't Arya simply ask Bran what lies west of Westeros?

The Logic vs. the Adventure Approach

"Oh that's precious, you are looking for logic in the last episode of Game of Thrones a show that had given up on logic four seasons ago," quipped one observer. This comment is certainly on point, as Game of Thrones often relied on narrative elements that defied conventional logic and relied more on the emotional and imaginative journeys of its characters.

Desire for Self-Discovery

One theory about Arya's reluctance to ask Bran stems from the desire for self-discovery and adventure. The show is rich with themes of exploration, and it's possible that Arya wanted to venture into the unknown without being influenced by preconceived notions or visions. She might have yearned for the thrill of experiencing things firsthand, free from any potential spoilers or preconceived expectations.

"It's meant to be an exploration, an adventure, a discovery. Even if Bran offered, she probably shot it down, OR he did, and she still wants to go," suggested another perspective. The idea here is that the act of going west is more important than the destination itself, symbolizing the journey of self-discovery.

Time Travel and Vision Limitations

Another interesting point is the limitations of Bran's abilities. Bran, with his Time of Ice powers, can only see others' memories and future memories, but only if they have traveled to the west. This implies that his power has geographical constraints, making his knowledge incomplete.

"Time travel logic. Bran can only see other people's memories/future memories. If no one travels to the west how can Bran recall their memories?" This question highlights the interconnected nature of the characters' journeys and the implications of their actions on Bran's visions.

Subtext and Character Intentions

When analyzing character intentions, it's crucial to consider both the explicit and implicit messaging. Arya's decision not to seek Bran's knowledge might suggest a deeper allegiance to her own path. She values her experiences and the lessons she learns through her own actions, rather than relying on outside information.

Arya might have held back because she didn't want to be told and instead wanted to find out for herself. This aligns with her character growth throughout the series, where she often proves her own abilities and character through direct action rather than accepting passive information.

Another possibility is that Bran simply told Arya, but she didn't care about his perspective. This could reflect a ongoing tension or a mutual disinterest between the two characters, particularly in the context of the series' final episodes.

Explicit Motivations and Cultural Myths

Arya's journey westward also draws from the rich tapestry of cultural myths and legends that permeate the game of thrones world. The idea of the Lands Without Death has long been a part of Westerosi folklore, and Arya's ship being named Nymeria (a character associated with escape and refuge) encapsulates her desire to find an escape from the trials and tribulations of Westeros.

The Books reveal that Rhaegar sent his son across the narrow sea, and years later, Arya fulfilled a similar role by crossing the sea to escape Westeros. This sequence of events aligns with the mythological theme of escape and refuge, as seen in the legends of Queen Nymeria, who took her people to the sea.

Unanswered Questions in the Finale

Another interesting aspect of this episode is the overlap with the books. The show's finale saw Arya's departure from Westeros, her ship named Nymeria, and the use of the Time of Ice to view the future, but these events were not as neatly tied together as in the books. Similarly, the ending of the series did not mention key characters like Tyrion Lannister and Aegon VI Targaryen (Prince That Was Promised), even though these characters were significant to the story.

The inclusion of Sam's incomplete book, A Song of Ice and Fire, in the finale was intended to remind viewers that the show was a fanfiction, constructed from George R.R. Martin's game of thrones world, and not a direct adaptation of the books. This adds another layer of complexity to the narrative, highlighting the series' construction and legacy.

Ultimately, Arya's decision not to ask Bran what lies west of Westeros can be seen as a character-driven moment that enriches the narrative, symbolizing self-discovery, adventure, and the intersection of cultural myths and personal journeys.