Examining Sansa's Role in Game of Thrones: A Critical Analysis

Game of Thrones has enthralled viewers with its intricate storytelling and complex characters. However, critical examination reveals discrepancies in certain behaviors.

Introduction to Sansa and Arya's Développement

The recent episode of Game of Thrones, specifically the first episode of Season 8, has sparked considerable discussion among fans. A pivotal moment where Arya accuses Sansa of lacking intelligence raises questions about character development and plot structure.

Smart or Stupid? Questions About Sansa's Intelligence

Sansa Stark, portrayed by Sophie Turner, is a well-rounded character who has undergone significant development throughout the series. Yet, in the ninth season, her perceived lack of intelligence raises eyebrows. This can be attributed to several factors:

1. Manipulation by Littlefinger: In the seventh season, it was revealed that Littlefinger was still manipulating Sansa, and she was unaware of his true intentions. This highlights Sansa's naivety in a world full of political maneuvering and hidden agendas.

2. Missteps in Political Communication: Sansa's public complaint about Daenerys' forces and dragons is a notable example. In a world where subtlety and diplomacy are paramount, her open criticism reflects a lack of strategic thinking. This behavior contrasts sharply with the wise and cautious approach of other characters like Arya and Bran.

3. Contradicting Authority: Sansa's challenge to Bran's authority in the Dragonpit further demonstrates a lack of political acumen. Her open defiance could have serious consequences for the North's stability and unity.

Contrasts and Expectations

Arya Stark, played by Maisie Williams, has come a long way. Her journey from non-conformity to a more traditional role as a heroine has been highlighted. Arya's need to travel more and engage with a wider circle of 'intelligent people' suggests a desire for growth beyond her focused and sometimes violent perspective.

Compared to Arya, Sansa's intelligence is often put into question. The writers might be using this to highlight the need for Sansa to mature and become a more effective leader. However, the dialogue and plot devices used to convey this message can be seen as somewhat unconvincing.

Critique of Season 8 Writings

The final season of Game of Thrones has faced criticism for its "shitty writing and crap dialogue". Many fans feel that the third and fourth episodes, in particular, deviate significantly from the dramatic and impactful tone established in seasons past. The disconnection between the characters' development and the overall narrative has been a point of contention, suggesting that the writing may have lost its way in the final season.

The portrayal of key characters like Sansa and Arya is seen as an example of this decline. Artistic choices that conflict with established character arcs often lead to a murky and confusing storyline, making it harder for viewers to connect with the events unfolding on screen.

Conclusion

The first episode of Game of Thrones season 8 raises important questions about character development and the role of intelligence in the medieval kingdom. While Sansa's actions and dialogue in the ninth season can be interpreted as signs of growth, viewers are left questioning whether the writers are truly committed to the consistency and depth of their narrative. The final season's critical reception highlights the importance of well-crafted storytelling in keeping audiences engaged and satisfied.