Enhancing the 2012 Les Misérables Film Adaptation: Critical Areas for Improvement

In the 2012 film adaptation of Les Misérables, one area that could have been improved is the vocal performances of certain characters. While the film features a star-studded cast, including Russell Crowe in the role of Javert, some performances did not meet the high expectations of the original musical.

Revisiting Javert’s Performance

Russell Crowe's portrayal of Javert was particularly criticized for lacking the vocal power and emotional depth required for the role. Crowe's performance could have been enhanced significantly if he had a background in musical theater or had received greater support in terms of vocal coaching. Additionally, the arrangement of Javert's songs could have been more nuanced to better convey the dramatic intensity of the character's struggles and conflicts.

Preserving Musical Elements

Another critical area that needs attention is the editing of musical numbers. The 2012 film has been criticized for cutting certain parts of the show's pivotal songs, such as the beginning of “On My Own” and the second verse of “Castle on a Cloud.” These cuts significantly impact the emotional resonance of the film and detract from the overall musical experience.

Emphasizing the Musical Aspect

The 2012 film should have been treated more like a musical than a traditional drama with singing. While the acting is top-notch, the focus on vocal beauty and power is often sacrificed in favor of dramatic elements. This creates a disjointed viewing experience, as the audience may struggle to align with the emotional weight conveyed through the music. A truly successful adaptation would seamlessly integrate the dramatic elements with the musical components, ensuring that both aspects work together to enhance the narrative.

Key Changes for Resonant Performances

For a more impactful and successful adaptation, several key changes should be made:

Replacement of Javert: Dropped Russell Crowe and cast a true musical performer. This would ensure that the character's emotional depth and vocal power are delivered effectively. Additional Vocal Coaching: Ensure all actors receive adequate vocal coaching to bring the songs to life with poetic and powerful vocals. Unedited Musical Numbers: Restore all the original musical numbers and refrain from cutting any critical parts of the songs.

In conclusion, while the 2012 film adaptation of Les Misérables is a commendable effort, it could be significantly enhanced by addressing the vocal performances and the musical structure. Introducing a cast with a stronger background in musical theater and ensuring that the film is treated as a musical would better resonate with audiences and capture the essence of this beloved classic.