Introduction

In the vast Harry Potter universe, the character of Albus Dumbledore has always been shrouded in mystery and intrigue. Among the myriad debates and discussions that persist among fanfiction authors and readers, one question stands out: should Dumbledore have married Grindelwald instead of McGonagall or Hermione? This article delves into the motivations, biases, and societal implications surrounding this theoretical path in Dumbledore's life.

Albus Dumbledore's Marital Choices

Throughout the Harry Potter series, Albus Dumbledore is portrayed as a highly influential and powerful figure, yet his personal life remains largely a mystery. Dumbledore has never married McGonagall or Hermione Granger in the canonical books or official film adaptations. However, the intricate world of fanfiction has engaged deeply with these characters, imagining alternative storylines where Dumbledore makes different choices.

McGonagall's Legacy

Serena McGonagall, better known as Minerva McGonagall, is a steadfast and loyal headmaster of Hogwarts. She is Albus Dumbledore's only known romantic partner in the official Harry Potter canon. When considering the argument for Dumbledore to marry McGonagall, one may focus on her reliability, intelligence, and steadfast loyalty to the school. As the deputy headmistress, she is deeply rooted in Hogwarts history, which aligns well with Dumbledore's own legacy and the importance of stability.

Hermione Granger's Charisma

Hermione Granger is a character known for her intelligence, bravery, and independence. Her relationship with Dumbledore is a significant plot point in Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, where a mature and kind Dumbledore interacts with a grown Hermione. However, her temporary separation from him at the end leaves readers pondering what could have been. A speculative marriage between Dumbledore and Hermione might be based on her strength and resilience, but it poses the question of how their intense relationship and history would have evolved.

Societal Views and Bisexuality Speculation

One reason for the interest in these alternative marriages is the belief that Dumbledore was bisexual. This theory comes from the character's close relationship with Gellert Grindelwald and sacrifices made to prevent Grindelwald's rise to power. In an interview with Carolyn Butcher on LinkedIn, Rowling herself stated, "He is gay. It had never occurred to me to give him a different sexuality. He was simply a gay man in that particular time and place."

The Impact of Victorian Society

The Victorian era setting of the Harry Potter universe introduces a level of societal expectation that complicates such a relationship. The Wizarding World shares many similar social norms with the real Victorian era. While actual records suggest that same-sex relationships might have existed in this context, the idea of legalization or official recognition of such unions is a concept that would not fit with the strict moral and ethical standards of the era.

Conclusion

In the complex and ever-evolving world of fan fiction, the idea of Dumbledore marrying either McGonagall or Hermione certainly introduces new layers of depth and intrigue to the Harry Potter narrative. However, the original canon and the clear bias displayed by Dumbledore towards purebloods, combined with the historical context of the Victorian era, suggest that such a marriage would have been met with significant societal and personal challenges. The exploration of these possibilities showcases the malleability and richness of the story world created by J.K. Rowling, inviting readers and writers alike to ponder the endless possibilities of the Harry Potter universe.

References

[1] Timeout London - J.K. Rowling on LinkedIn [2] Harry Potter - Pottermore - The Cursed Child