Introduction

In the complex web of relationships within the Harry Potter series, the dynamics between Draco Malfoy and Hermione Granger have often been a subject of debate and interpretation. This essay explores the nuanced perspectives on Draco's feelings towards Hermione, challenges the notion of Draco secretly loving Hermione, and discusses the implications of Hermione's actions in the sixth book.

Theoretical Context: Draco's Attitude Towards Hermione

Many readers and critics have suggested that Draco Malfoy harbored deep-seated feelings of hatred and even dislike towards Hermione Granger. However, a close examination of the text and character interactions reveals a different picture. While it is clear that Draco despised Hermione for the simple fact that she was what he considered to be a threat and an obstacle, there is no substantial evidence to support the idea that he had any positive feelings towards her.

Theory vs. Canon: Hermione's Dismissal of Harry's Theory

The sixth book, specifically during the events surrounding the defeat of Lord Voldemort, presents a pivotal moment where Hermione dismisses Harry's theory about Draco's actions. This scene has stirred considerable debate, with some arguing that Hermione's sudden unwillingness to trust Harry is a significant flaw in her character development. However, evidence from the canon world suggests a different interpretation.

Hermione's dismissal of Harry's theory can be understood as a result of her own experiences and the matters at hand. Hermione, known for her studious and bookish nature, may have initially hesitated to accept a theory not based on direct evidence. Her confidence in her own abilities and her belief in the importance of genuine knowledge and understanding come into play, leading her to question theories not grounded in concrete facts.

It is important to note that Hermione's character is consistently portrayed as someone who values truth, accurate information, and solid evidence. This is evident in her refusal to believe in unfounded theories or conjecture. While her actions can be seen as independent and sometimes stubborn, they are rooted in her core principles and not necessarily a sign of mistrust.

Cultural Context: Draco's Treatment of Hermione

Contrary to common fan theories, Draco Malfoy did not merely despise Hermione; he dehumanized her. He never merely disrespected or questioned her ability, but went further by questioning her very personhood. The dehumanization of Hermione by Draco is a severe form of bigotry and hatred, exemplified through derogatory language and taunts that remind one of horrific usage of racial slurs in other contexts.

While Harry and Ron, though they disrespected Hermione at times, never dehumanized her by questioning her magical ability, her worth, or her very existence. Hermione remained normal to them, a friend, a peer, and a title that referred to her as a witch, not a member of an oppressed group. This is a crucial distinction that underscores Draco's far more sinister and dehumanizing treatment of Hermione.

Fan Fiction vs. Canon: The Secret Admiration Myth

Another common fan fiction theory posits that Draco Malfoy secretly held romantic feelings for Hermione Granger. However, the idea that Draco secretly loved Hermione lacks substantial textual evidence and is unsupported in the canon. Hermione's status as a muggle-born in Gryffindor and her friendship with Harry and Ron present significant barriers to Draco's romantic interest.

Hermione's appearance and personality were never aligned with Draco's desired traits in a romantic partner. The character profiles suggest that Hermione's strong-willed nature and bookish demeanor were antithetical to what Draco sought in a romantic interest. Her intelligence and loyalty to her friends also stand in direct opposition to his reputation for cunning and loyalty to his own house.

Conclusion

In summary, the relationship between Draco Malfoy and Hermione Granger is complex and multi-faceted. Draco's feelings towards Hermione were rooted in dehumanization and hatred, not romanticism. Hermione's actions in the sixth book can be interpreted as maintaining her principles and valuing accurate information, rather than a sudden loss of trust in her friends. Understanding these dynamics through the lens of canon provides a more accurate portrayal of the characters' interactions and their place in the broader narrative of the Harry Potter series.