Do 'Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker' and 'The Mandalorian' Contradict Past Star Wars Media?

The release of 'Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker' (ROS) and the ongoing popularity of The Mandalorian have sparked debates about their consistency with previous 'Star Wars' media. Some critics argue that these new entries, particularly ROS, contradict events from earlier films and series. However, a closer examination reveals that both projects serve different purposes and contribute to the rich tapestry of the Star Wars universe in their own unique ways.

The Rise of Skywalker

'Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker' has been criticized for its numerous plot holes and its attempts to wrap up unresolved storylines with a sharp pivot that makes earlier events meaningless. Some viewers argue that the return of Emperor Palpatine and the notion that Anakin Skywalker did not, in fact, restore balance to the Force invalidate the grand arc of the Star Wars saga. They contend that Anakin's sacrifice in 'Return of the Jedi' was rendered null and void, essentially nullifying the entire Chosen One narrative.

Many point out that this decision takes away from the emotional and heroic arcs of beloved characters and creates a sense of disrespect towards the legacy established in earlier movies. The introduction of new characters to replace old favorites is seen as a betrayal by both fans and critics. The movie's departure from established lore is often cited as the reason for its low regard among audiences who cherished the definitive series of films.

The Mandalorian and Its Approach

'The Mandalorian,' on the other hand, has been praised for its seamless integration into the 'Star Wars' universe. The series, particularly in its second season, has tackled some longstanding questions and controversies with a refreshing approach. Unlike ROS, which is criticized for contradicting past works, avoids direct contradiction by steering clear of major plot points that would invalidate earlier works. Instead, it addresses lingering questions and expands our understanding of the galaxy far, far away.

While some viewers were disappointed to find out that certain Mandalorian knowledge from 'Republic Commando' novels was not canon, the show managed to navigate these inconsistencies by aligning with the The Clone Wars series. Characters and events from these earlier stories are not outright contradicted but rather recontextualized for a new audience. This approach is seen as more respectful and engaging, as it allows for the legacy to be carried forward without severing ties with the past.

Legacy and Respect

The article's author expresses a strong sentiment against the recent sequels, citing their disappointment in how the heroes they grew up with were portrayed. This sentiment is echoed by many who feel a deep attachment to the characters and storylines that made 'Star Wars' an integral part of their childhood. However, the second season of 'The Mandalorian' has managed to reignite this passion in a way that honors the legacy without negating it.

One of the key factors in 'The Mandalorian's' success is its commitment to portraying the 'Star Wars' universe as a place of love and respect. The last ten minutes of the series' second season are seen as a personal apology to the fans, rectifying many of the issues that the previous films left unresolved. By embracing the past and adding new layers of depth to existing lore, 'The Mandalorian' has not only won over many critics but also rekindled the spirit of wonder and adventure that defined the original 'Star Wars' saga.

In conclusion, while both 'Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker' and 'The Mandalorian' address the 'Star Wars' universe in different ways, the latter is praised for its respect towards the past and its ability to enrich the legacy without contradicting it. As the 'Star Wars' universe continues to expand, viewers hope that future projects will follow suit in honoring the rich tapestry that makes the franchise so beloved.