Do People Who Have Read Lord of the Rings After Watching the Movies Still Find It an Interesting Read?

When discussing The Lord of the Rings, it's natural to wonder which format—books or movies—provides the best experience. Many who have experienced it in both forms often share that reading the books offers a level of detail and depth that movies can only hint at. Here are some reasons why even those who have seen the films find the books a fascinating and rewarding read.

Enhanced Understanding of the One Ring’s Power

The Lord of the Rings, by J.R.R. Tolkien, is renowned not just for its epic storytelling but for its intricate world-building. One aspect that stands out is the power of the One Ring. In the movies, the Ring's power is simplified, and the idea is presented in a straightforward manner: it grants immense power to Sauron but prevents others from using it effectively (except perhaps Galadriel or Gandalf).

However, in the books, Tolkien elaborates on the concept of "Power according to one's stature." This means that the Ring's influence multiplies whatever skills a person already has, but with the risk of corruption. The book delves deeply into who can use the Ring and the extent of its influence. For instance, Samwise Gamgee makes significant use of the Ring in Mordor, a detail that the films significantly downplay, focusing instead on a general sense of dread and unexplainable power.

Delving into Character Details with Tom Bombadil

Another notable aspect of the books that often gets overlooked in the films is the character of Tom Bombadil. This enigmatic figure appears early in The Fellowship of the Ring and is described as a mysterious Nature Spirit, possibly a Vala or a Maia. Tom's unique ability to control nature through song is a fascinating element that enriches the story with its magical and whimsical touch.

Peter Jackson’s adaptation didn’t include Tom Bombadil's sequence, deeming it a detour. While this decision helped keep the films within a more manageable length, it arguably diminished the rich character development and the unique storytelling that Tom Bombadil brings to the narrative.

The Extended Denouement

A third advantage of reading the books is the extensive denouement that follows the events of Mount Doom. In the films, this section is considerably shorter, glossing over several key developments. The books provide a detailed account of the Hobbits’ return to the Shire, where they discover that Saruman, of all people, has taken control.

This narrative twist is pivotal in emphasizing that even in the aftermath of Sauron's defeat, the burden of governance and problem-solving falls on the Hobbits, survivors of the great and powerful. This section underscores Tolkien's message that evil is never completely vanquished; it is the responsibility of humans, or mortals, to address their own challenges.

Conclusion

While the movies offer an engaging and immersive experience, reading the books provides a more nuanced and detailed exploration of the characters, plot, and themes of The Lord of the Rings. For those who have already seen the films, revisiting the books can be a rewarding experience, highlighting the depth and richness of Tolkien's creation.