Did Jon Arryn Prefer Robert Baratheon to Ned Stark?

The relationship between Jon Arryn, Robert Baratheon, and Ned Stark in emA Song of Ice and Fire/em and emGame of Thrones/em is complex and multifaceted. While the books and TV show do not explicitly state Jon's preference between the two, there are implications and instances that offer insight into his feelings.

Background: The Hand of the King

Jon Arryn, the Hand of the King, had a deep relationship with both Robert and Ned. He was both Robert's foster father and Ned's

Respect and Fondness

Jon Arryn respected Ned Stark deeply, particularly for his honor and integrity. This is evident through their shared experiences and interactions. For instance, they grew up together in the Vale of Arryn, becoming close companions and considering him a second father. This bond suggests a mutual respect and affection between the two.

However, Arryn also had a close relationship with Robert Baratheon. Their bond was rooted in their shared past. Despite the years that had passed, Arryn recognized the headstrong but ultimately loyal nature of Bob

Robert and Ned maintained a different kind of relationship, with Ned often chiding Robert for his sourpuss demeanor and Robert occasionally joking with Ned. These interactions suggest a more lighthearted and familiar dynamic between Jon and Robert, one that Ned may not have shared to the same degree.

Jon’s Decision: The New Hand

Arryn's decision to summon Ned Stark to serve as the new Hand after his death further suggests his belief in Ned's character and suitability for the role. While Arryn likely had a fondness for Robert due to their long history, he recognized the qualities in Ned that made him a more trustworthy and reliable choice for the role of Hand.

Gifts and Companionship

There are a few instances where Jon appeared closer to Robert. For example, Jon named his son Robin, or as Ned calls him, "Lord Robert," while Robert named his son Joffrey. Both names start with 'R.' This similarity could indicate a shared sense of camaraderie and shared experiences. Additionally, Jon and Robert shared gifts, such as a hunting knife, implying a deep connection and mutual understanding.

Furthermore, Ned had a vivid dream of a tournament where Jaime was knighted. In his dream, he saw Jon and Robert bickering, suggesting a shared sense of humor and companionship that Ned did not share with them.

Conclusion: Equally Precious

In the end, while there may have been a slight preference or stronger bond between Jon and Robert, it is important to note that Ned was equally precious to Jon. Both Robert and Ned loved Jon as a second father, and Jon loved them equally, albeit for different reasons. Jon's choice to name his son after Robert and their shared gifts highlight a special connection that went beyond mere friendship.

Ultimately, Jon Arryn's choice of Ned Stark as the new Hand suggests a deeper understanding of Ned's character and his suitability for the role, indicating a past where Jon valued Ned’s qualities more than Robert's headstrong nature.