Did Game of Thrones S7E5 Confirm Jon Snow’s Legitimacy?

For many fans of the TV series Game of Thrones, the seventh season finale episode 5 presented a significant revelation regarding Jon Snow. Many question whether the episode confirmed that Jon Snow is not a bastard after all, and whether this would substantially impact the storyline. Let's delve into the potential implications.

Is Jon Snow Legitimate?

Unfortunately for some fans, the answer is yes. The episode provided strong evidence that Jon Snow may indeed be the legitimate son of Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark. This is frustrating for those who believed that Jon would not benefit from every imaginable advantage. However, it's important to note that this means a war could still occur since Rhaegar and Lyanna's union would have been consummated even without Jon's legitimacy.

Furthermore, the children of Elia and Rhaegar, Rhaenys and Aegon, are identified as bastards due to their parents' apparent affair. explaining Jon’s legitimacy more straightforwardly to the audience.

Jon's Legitimacy: A Legal Perspective

Assuming the most likely theory that Jon is the son of Rhaegar and Lyanna, there is strong evidence to support this conclusion. We know that Lyanna had a baby in secret, and she pleaded to Ned Stark to protect her child from "him." The director cut from the baby’s eyes to Jon Snow’s eyes suggests a familial connection. Additionally, it is implied that Rhaegar had fled with Lyanna. These assumptions might seem like wishful thinking, but given the elements of drama, it's reasonable to assume this is the case.

Further Evidence for Jon's Legitimacy

Furthermore, we know that Rhaegar “got an annulment” and “got secretly remarried in Dorne.” The Citadel has 15,782 steps, a detail that some theorize could imply a legitimate union. However, it's crucial to remember that these assumptions are still unconfirmed. Jon would only be considered legitimate if we can confirm both of these events.

Jon's Identity and the Legitimacy Debate

It is important to note that the episode did not officially confirm Jon's legitimacy. The director's cut and Drogon touching scene strongly suggested that Rhaegar and Lyanna's union was legitimized through an official wedding. Nevertheless, this legibility is yet to be officially confirmed. Jon Snow is still a bastard until this is verified.

The turning point for Jon may come from the scrolls that Sam was forced to copy. Gilly reading a book with them when they left hints at potential information. While Sam does not seem particularly interested, there is a chance that the details of the annulment and secret ceremony will eventually come to light. This information could reveal Jon's true status as the legitimate heir to the throne.

The Current Status and Future Implications

Despite the strong evidence, many fans still believe that Rhaegar kidnapped Lyanna, and Jon is Ned's bastard. Without more convincing evidence or characters like Howland Reed revealing the truth, Jon may continue to face challenges to his legitimacy.

The season's finale episode 5 of Game of Thrones might have tipped some scales in favor of Jon's legitimacy, but the debate remains open. Fans can hope that future episodes will provide more conclusive evidence and clarity.