Cruella de Ville: A Comparative Analysis of Emma Stone and Glenn Close

In recent years, the character of Cruella de Ville has come to life in various adaptations, with two notable actresses, Emma Stone and Glenn Close, taking on the iconic villainous role.

Emma Stone's Cruella de Ville

Emma Stone, known for her versatility and talent in the film industry, gave a convincing performance as Cruella de Ville in the 2016 live-action film. Despite some mixed reviews, Stone's portrayal of the character showcases her ability to channel multiple dimensions of Cruella's personality, from her fashionista quirks to her ruthless nature.

Glenn Close's Cruella de Ville

Glenn Close, a veteran actress, also brought her own unique touch to the character in 1996's 101 Dalmatians. Her interpretation, while faithful to the original animated film, faced criticism for the heavy makeup and hair transformation, which some felt overshadowed her acting prowess. However, her depth as a performer shone through, despite the physical alterations.

Personal Preferences and Critique

Personal preferences often play a significant role in debates about which actress fits the role better. Some viewers, such as Jason, argue that Emma Stone stands out as the better choice, citing her positive reception and powerful acting skills. In contrast, Glenn Close's portrayal drew more criticism, with some viewers finding her role too exaggerated and less nuanced.

Alternative Performances and Future Adaptations

Jason also mentions a third choice, Victoria Smurfit, from the television series Once Upon a Time. Smurfit's performance, while not mainstream, received praise for its authenticity and character depth. Additionally, Christine Baranski, known for her versatility and presence, could have brought a fresh and nuanced interpretation to the role, according to Jason.

Call for Prequel Stories and Improvement

There is a palpable interest in exploring the origins of Cruella de Ville, with Jason expressing a desire for a prequel that delves into her past. This could provide a deeper understanding of the character's motivations and development, bringing a fresh perspective to the beloved villain. It is hoped that future adaptations will focus on character development rather than exaggerated physical transformations.

In conclusion, while both Emma Stone and Glenn Close effectively embodied Cruella de Ville in their respective films, personal preferences and critical reception play a key role in determining who is better suited for the role. Continuous improvements in future adaptations could lead to more nuanced and memorable portrayals of this iconic character.