Critical Analysis of the Raazi 2018 Film: A Spouse, Spy, and the Tricolour Scene

Introduction

"Raazi" is a 2018 Hindi thriller film based on the book by Harinder Sikka. Directed by Meghna Gulzar, the movie centers around Sehmat, a young Kashmiri girl who agrees to marry a Pakistani Army officer to spy for India. However, personal and moral dilemmas arise as the plot unfolds. This article analyzes the film’s plot, character development, and the removal of a significant scene from the National Award-winning book.

Plot and Character Development

The film aims for a financial thriller with a fresh and twisty plot. While praising the concept, numerous viewers found it disappointing and unenjoyable. Alia Bhatt's performance, particularly her screeching in certain scenes, led to a negative reaction from some viewers. The protagonist's journey from a spy posing as a young bride to her struggle with moral righteousness is a central theme of the film. The climax of the movie involves her delivering a heartfelt speech to her superior, which is perceived as inconsistent and misplaced.

Criticisms and Personal Reactions

Personal reactions to the film are highly varied. The author found the plot preposterous, particularly the part where the idealistic spy preaches about humanity to her superior. The author’s sentiment is that the movie is more about a cry for help, rather than a thrilling narrative. The problem lies in her assertion of moral superiority at the end. This is not a unique sentiment; many viewers express similar frustration with the narrative choices.

Author's Perspective and Omission

Harinder Sikka, the author of the book "Calling Sehmat, " was not satisfied with the film adaptation. He regrets the omission of the 'tricolour scene' from the movie. In the book, the story ends with Sehmat saluting the tricolour, a significant moment that would have secured the National Award for the film.

It is the director's prerogative to make changes in the adaptation. The author states that the removal of this scene was done with the filmmakers' agreement. However, Sikka still feels resentment over this decision. This omission highlights the tension between the source material and its film adaptation.

Reflections on Cultural and National Identity

The film raises questions about cultural and national identity, particularly in the context of Kashmir. Harinder Sikka mentions that such stories are important to understand and respect. He emphasizes that not all Kashmiri Muslims are terrorists, and there are individuals who have dedicated their lives to their country. This perspective is crucial in the broader context of conflicts and stereotypes.

Conclusion

The film "Raazi" presents a complex narrative that engages with themes of identity, loyalty, and morality. While it successfully addresses these themes, the plot points and dialogue raise questions for some viewers. The removal of significant scenes from the book further complicates the narrative, highlighting the challenges of adapting stories for the silver screen. Despite its shortcomings, the film remains a noteworthy exploration of a national hero's journey.