Could Count Dooku Be the Ideal Successor in the Jedi Order?

In the ever-evolving narrative of the Star Wars Jedi Order, one might wonder if Count Dooku could have ascended to the position of Grand Master if certain conditions were met.

Assuming Smooth Succession

Let's consider a scenario where the future unfolds more smoothly for the Jedi Order. Mace Windu, alongside Count Dooku, successfully apprehends Darth Sidious. Sidious meets his demise, either through assassination or a brief trial. A year later, Yoda, foreseeing his retirement, steps down as the Grand Master.

The Election Process and Criteria

Under the Star Wars universe, the Jedi Council holds the ultimate power to elect a new Grand Master. Given that Yoda's decision can be overruled by a majority vote, it is imperative that the council members weigh their decisions carefully.

Why Dooku Might Not Be the Ideal Candidate

Several factors make Count Dooku an unlikely candidate for the position of Grand Master:

Leadership Experience: Dooku has never served on the Jedi Council, meaning he lacks the necessary experience in governing the Order's affairs or setting policies. His disagreements with the council have made building a majority among his peers nearly impossible.

Outsider Status: The council is highly unlikely to elect an outsider. Phonetically, an absence of council experience and trust from current members makes Dooku a potential political risk.

Public Image: With Palpatine out of the picture, the Jedi would need someone who can repair relationships with the Senate and the public. Dooku's close ties to the Confederacy would make him extremely unpopular, complicating the delicate political climate.

Desire for Radical Change: As a proponent of change, Dooku would fit poorly into a time demanding stability. The Jedi Order, still reeling from conflict, would prefer a leader who can maintain stability for a considerable period.

Age: Assuming Dooku remains alive, his advanced age (around 85) would make the search for a successor even more urgent. Experience and wisdom are vital qualities that the Jedi Council recognizes, making Dooku less ideal.

Other Suitable Candidates

With Dooku unlikely to be the chosen successor, one must look at other potential candidates:

Mace Windu: The Ideal Candidate

At 55 years old, Mace Windu would almost certainly be elected. His experience includes being a member of the Jedi Council since the age of 28, effectively serving nearly three decades. His time as the "Acting Grand Master" further qualifies him. Elected by a landslide, Mace would bring extensive experience and the necessary leadership qualities to the role.

Obi-Wan Kenobi: A Decent Choice

Obi-Wan Kenobi is an excellent choice, though he misses the critical experience of being a council member. During the Clone Wars, Kenobi spent much of his time as a general, leading missions related to the conflict. Despite his skills and wisdom, his lack of council experience would make him less suitable for immediate leadership.

Kenobi as Vice Grand Master

While Obi-Wan Kenobi may not be the first choice for the top position, he could serve as the Vice Grand Master, supporting the chosen leader and gaining the necessary experience over time.

In conclusion, while Count Dooku might make for a bold and controversial Grand Master, the intricate balance of the Jedi Order's stability, leadership experience, and public support make him an unsuitable candidate for the role. Mace Windu's extensive experience and Kenobi's strong leadership potential offer the best options for guiding the Jedi Order through its uncertain future.