Comparing the Robots in 'Westworld' (Original vs. HBO Series)

Westworld, the original film and the HBO series, both explore the concept of advanced robotics in distinct ways. While the original Westworld featured more human-like robots, the HBO series delves deeper into the complexities of robotics and the nature of humanity.

The Machines of Westworld (Original)

In the original Westworld, the robots were designed to look and act very human. They had skin, clothing, and behavior patterns that made them almost indistinguishable from human actors. The visual design was so advanced that visitors to the park often had trouble recognizing the difference between the machines and the humans. As a result, the robots' motivations and humanity were not a central focus. They were programmed specifically for 'play violence' and their actions were largely pre-determined.

The Advanced Technology in HBO Westworld

In contrast, the robots in the HBO version of Westworld are more advanced and less humanoid in appearance. They retain certain human-like qualities, but are also depicted as more mechanical and less natural. One notable element in the series is the use of insect-like robots (flies) by Charlotte to control humans and even other robots. These flies are used to transmit orders from unseen humans, adding another layer of complexity to the machine-human interaction.

Concepts and Themes

The HBO series focuses on exploring themes of what it means to be human, with robots playing a central role. One key difference is that in the original, the robots' motivations were less complex and more straightforward. For instance, a sex bot in the original film refused a sexual advance, indicating a level of autonomy, albeit limited. However, the HBO series digs deeper into this idea of autonomy and whether robots can truly have their own motivations.

The idea of revenge is also a significant theme in the HBO series, particularly in the missions of the Man in Black, who has a more complex backstory in the series than in the film. The Man in Black's actions in the series are driven by a desire for revenge and a deeper sense of purpose than in the original. The series delves into the idea of agency and self-determination, which is not as prominent in the film.

Plot and Moral Dilemmas

The original film focuses on the chase of a killer machine, a plot element that is echoed in parts of the HBO series. However, while the original film's moral dilemma stems from hubris, akin to Jurassic Park, the HBO series offers a more nuanced exploration of control, autonomy, and the consequences of human actions.

The HBO series also shifts the narrative perspective, giving more voice and agency to the robots themselves. The first episode of the series centers on the robots, while the second episode shifts to the guests. This perspective shift suggests that the series is building towards a collision of these two worlds, where the distinction between human and machine is increasingly blurred.

Conclusion

Both the original Westworld film and the HBO series offer unique insights into the future of robotics and the nature of humanhood. While the original film is more focused on the clear distinction between robots and humans, the HBO series takes a more complex and nuanced look at the boundary between the two. Whether you prefer the visual spectacle and straightforward narrative of the film or the intricate, thought-provoking storytelling of the HBO series, both are compelling explorations of the themes of humanity and artificial intelligence.