Comparing 'Wicked' the Musical and the Book

When it comes to discussing the Wicked musical versus the book, opinions are divided. Both have their unique charm and value, each tailored to different audience preferences. In this article, we will delve into the pros and cons of both the musical and the book adaptation of Wicked, as well as the impact of the staying devilish trend amidst the current pandemic.

Challenges in Adaptation: Creativity and Popularization

The decision to adapting the story of Wicked for the stage is often debated. Critics argue that the creators of the musical took a story that already existed and altered its narrative to give its villain, Elphaba, sympathetic traits. This approach has received mixed reviews. While the adaptation was praised for its innovative storytelling, some felt that it deviated too much from the original book, diluting its intended message and complexity.

Special effects in the musical, such as Idina Menzel flying, may have been impressive historically, but they have since become common and may not stand out as uniquely magical to today's audience. The simplicity and starkness of the original book's villains might have been intentional, providing a clearer contrast and deeper engagement with the characters' backstories and motivations. However, the musical's focus on these elements through a different lens makes it a compelling stage production on its own terms.

The Impact of the Pandemic on Theater

Amidst the ongoing coronavirus pandemic, the Wicked musical has faced significant challenges. Theatrical productions have had to close or schedule events for later dates due to public health guidelines. For instance, the Suggestion Center, a prominent venue, had to cancel all events through April 13, including ongoing shows of the traveling Broadway musical. Similarly, the Wisconsin Film Festival was postponed indefinitely.

The decision to cancel these events came after a request by Public Health Madison and Dane County, highlighting the broader impact of the pandemic on cultural and entertainment venues. While some alternative forms of entertainment, such as cinema, have remained open, the trend of staying devilish (i.e., maintaining the original character without over-sympathizing the antagonist) has been observed in these adaptations.

Value in Both Formats

Despite the challenges, both the musical and the book have their unique merits. The musical does an excellent job of translating the book to the stage, especially in terms of music and overall production quality. Certain aspects, like the character of Fiyero, are crafted well for the stage. However, the story, narrative depth, and world-building in the book are incomparable. They offer a richer and more nuanced exploration of the characters and their journeys.

For those who prefer a deep and complex world, the book provides an experience that is akin to diving into a fully-realized fantasy novel. The musical, on the other hand, captures the spirit and energy of live performance, making it a powerful stage production that resonates with audiences in a different way.

Conclusion: Both Are Good, Just Different

Honestly, I appreciate both the musical and the book. The musical excels in its innovation and the quality of its music, while the book remains a powerful and rich narrative with complex characters and a detailed world. Both works offer unique perspectives and value to their respective audiences. The challenge of adaptation, enhanced by the current pandemic, underscores the different strengths and weaknesses of each format, making it clear that both are good in their own right, just in different ways.

Whether you are a lover of stage performance or a reader, both Wicked the musical and the book offer unique experiences that can be enjoyed independently or together. As we continue to navigate the challenges presented by the pandemic, it is reassuring to have these narratives available as a respite and a reminder of the enduring power of storytelling.