Can Historic Novels Be Written Without Being Historically Accurate?

Historic novels have long been a subject of debate in the world of literature. One of the key questions surrounding this genre is whether these novels can be written without being historically accurate. In today’s post, we explore the realities of historical accuracy in novels, debunking the myth that such a thing is achievable or even desirable.

The Uncertainty of Historical Records

First and foremost, it's important to acknowledge the inherent uncertainty when it comes to historical records. Nobody is 100% sure about what happened, how it happened, and how people exactly lived and thought in history. The study of history, a humanistic science, is riddled with controversial and scarce written resources. This means that even the most meticulous historical studies and works cannot claim absolute accuracy.

The Illusion of Historical Accuracy

When a historical novel is said to be “historically accurate,” it simply implies that the story aligns with the common understanding of history held by the audience. This is more of a literary device than a factual assertion. For instance, many readers may believe certain events or figures from history to be true, but those beliefs are often based on inaccuracies or myths that have been passed down through the ages. Thus, historical accuracy as a concept becomes quite subjective.

Audience Expectations and Common Knowledge

It’s crucial to remember that your audience, which comprises ordinary people, lacks a comprehensive understanding of history. Most people’s knowledge about history is often vague or completely wrong. For example, many popular historical films and novels have a distorted view of historical events and figures. This is not due to malicious intent but is a result of simplification and dramatic license necessary for storytelling.

The Practicalities of Perfect Accuracy

Even if a time machine were invented and one could claim absolute historical accuracy, it would still face significant practical challenges. Actual people from the past are remarkably different from the modern audiences' perceptions. A historical setting would be extremely alien and challenging to set up for an audience, with very little payoff in terms of engaging the reader. This disparity can create a disconnect between the reader and the narrative, making the story less relatable.

The Importance of Artistic License

Novels, especially those in the historical genre, must often prioritize artistic and narrative value over historical accuracy. The goal is to engage and captivate the audience, which is often impossible to achieve if the story feels too dry or disconnected from modern sensibilities. Historical accuracy can sometimes come at the expense of storytelling, resulting in a less compelling narrative.

A Call to Embrace Inexactness

In conclusion, don’t stress over the quest for historical accuracy in novels. The concept of historical accuracy is largely illusory. By embracing the creative liberties offered by writing, authors can craft stories that resonate with contemporary audiences, thereby achieving the primary goal of engaging the reader emotionally and intellectually.

So, the next time you sit down to pen a historic novel, remember that your primary goal is to tell a compelling story. The historical facts, while important, can take a backseat to the narrative’s richness and the reader's engagement.