Can DC Improve Its Movie Making Standard More Than Marvel?

As a long-time MCU fan, I remain optimistic about the potential for the DC Extended Universe (DCEU) to elevate its movie-making standards. The franchise has indeed faced challenges, with films like Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice marking a decline from its earlier successes such as Man of Steel and Wonder Woman. However, after viewing the recent The Snyder Cut of The Justice League, it's clear that the DCEU possesses untapped potential. I urge DC to maintain its darker, more grounded tone and to allow directors full creative freedom, much like what Warner Bros. anticipated and ultimately failed to honor with the theatrical release of Justice League.

The Potentials and Challenges

Improving DC's movie-making standards will require some key changes. One major issue is redirecting Zack Snyder, an artist who, while talented, tends to overemphasize grounded and dull narratives when directing. His influence in films like Man of Steel and Batman v Superman often leads to storytelling that becomes too grounded and less suitable for the larger-than-life characters. For instance, Man of Steel's dark tone, while appropriate for the opening scene of Superman's introduction, may not have been the best fit overall.

Batman v Superman encountered significant issues due to its heavy-handed approach in portraying dark elements without addressing it effectively within the character's context. The film introduced a disturbing twist by making Batman a murderer, which contradicted the essence of the character and the core premise. It's vital for the filmmakers to find a balance between dark and comic relief to cater to the diverse audience.

Learn from Marvel, Don't Mimic It

Unlike what the DCEU has done in recent years, there's no need to attempt to mimic Marvel's success formula. DC has the unique opportunity to adapt its narrative style to suit its characters and storylines more organically. For example, Shazam succeeded because it embraced the humor intrinsic to its character, knowing that an adolescent with superpowers would naturally provide comedic elements. It's important to recall that while Marvel has achieved great commercial success, their storytelling methods have become somewhat predictable and rigid.

By contrast, DC has the capability to be more versatile. Their films can be dark and gritty when needed, as seen in The Snyder Cut, while also light-hearted when appropriate, as demonstrated in Shazam. The formulaic approach of Marvel works well for their particular amalgamation of characters but may not be the best fit for DC's diverse roster.

Avoiding a Never-ending Competition

The films from DC have often felt like direct responses to Marvel's successes, leading to a sense of competition rather than innovation. Batman v Superman was seen as a direct response to Civil War, and Justice League was positioned as a counterpoint to The Avengers. This chase to outdo Marvel has not only diluted the originality of DC's films but also detracted from the unique voices and storytelling styles of individual filmmakers and screenwriters.

DC should consider slowing down and focusing on developing stronger, more creative storytelling for individual characters. A future Wonder Woman sequel and a standalone Batman movie would be excellent steps in the right direction. Additionally, a reboot of Suicide Squad directed by James Gunn, the man behind the popular Guardians of the Galaxy franchise, holds promise. On the other hand, a reboot of Birds of Prey that brings back Barbara Gordon is essential to honor the legacy and importance of such a significant character within the series.

In conclusion, while DC has faced challenges in recent years, the franchise still possesses the potential to create a more unique and superior movie-making standard. By letting go of the competition mindset, avoiding over-corporation by Zack Snyder, and maintaining a flexible narrative approach, DC can produce films that celebrate the full scope of its rich universe of characters.