Brienne of Tarth: Beauty Beyond Appearance in ‘A Song of Ice and Fire’

Brienne of Tarth, one of the most memorable characters from George R.R. Martin’s epic fantasy series A Song of Ice and Fire and its adaptation Game of Thrones, challenges the conventional notion of beauty and virtue. Despite her physically imposing and masculine figure, Brienne is celebrated for her honor, loyalty, and bravery, rather than her appearance. This article explores her character, the public perception of her appearance, and the underlying themes of beauty and virtue in the series.

Character Description in the Books vs. the Show

In the books, Brienne is explicitly described as an ugly and masculine figure, a choice that some viewers found unrealistically negative. In contrast, the focus in the show is more on her inner strength and prowess. Gwendoline Christie, who played Brienne in the show, was praised for her portrayal, but the portrayal of her appearance remained less than ideal according to the book’s descriptions. Her short hair and mannish clothing, along with her height and strength, contributed to the perception of her as a fearsome and intimidating figure.

The Contradiction Between Appearance and Inner Strength

The juxtaposition of Brienne’s physical appearance with her inner virtues is a recurring theme in A Song of Ice and Fire. Her masculine build and height are often commented upon by characters, yet her fighting skills and loyalty stand out. She is a woman who has earned respect through her actions, rather than her appearance. This contrast highlights the idea that true beauty lies not only in physical attractiveness but also in the values and virtues one embodies.

Character Evaluation and Undeniable Strength

While some characters criticize Brienne’s appearance, others, like Jaime Lannister, recognize her worth beyond her looks. Jaime’s observation that Brienne would have been as lauded as Barristan the Bold if she had been born a man illustrates the significance of her character traits. Brienne’s ability to defeat Sandor Clegane, one of the best warriors in Westeros, is a testament to her formidable strength and skill. This skill is far more impactful than any perceived ugliness, as it speaks to her bravery and determination.

Inner Beauty and Virtuous Heart

Besides her physical appearance and fighting abilities, Brienne is celebrated for her inner character. She has a heart of gold and the moral compass of a true knight. Her straightforward and naive nature, while sometimes seen as a flaw, is endearing and aligns with her dedication to honor and duty. Her role as the Lady Commander of the Kingsguard is a fitting culmination of her journey, emphasizing the respect she has earned through her actions and virtues.

Addressing Misconceptions with Humor

The series frequently employs humor to address these misconceptions. A memorable scene from the show features a man who wishes for a softer, more feminine Brienne, only to have her demonstrate her strength and prowess, turning his notion of beauty on its head. This scene underscores the idea that true beauty lies in one’s character and actions rather than physical attributes.

In conclusion, Brienne of Tarth is a character that challenges traditional notions of beauty and virtue. Her portrayal in the books and show reflects a deeper exploration of these concepts. While some may view her as ugly, her actions and inner strength make her a compelling and admirable figure. Her story is a testament to the importance of inner qualities over physical appearance, making her a valuable addition to the rich tapestry of characters in A Song of Ice and Fire.