Breaking the Screenwriting Rules: A Call to Creativity and Originality

Screenwriting, like any other form of storytelling, thrives on rules, but in the world of screenwriting, these rules often feel more like restrictions than guidelines. Over the decades, a screenwriting “priesthood” has emerged, imposing rigid structures and strict guidelines that can stifle creativity. In this article, we explore the impact of these rules, the nuances of breaking them, and offer a path towards a more creative and individualistic approach to storytelling.

The Screenwriting Priesthood

The “priesthood” of screenwriting, composed of authors, university instructors, seminar teachers, and script analysts, sees itself as gatekeepers, holding the keys to the kingdom of success. They believe that only those who strictly adhere to their rules can achieve fulfillment and success. However, as Peter Guber eloquently argues, their rules often come at the expense of originality and creativity.

The Limitations of Rigid Screenwriting Rules

One of the most notable flaws of these rigid rules is the emphasis they place on format and structure. For instance, the requirement for a 12-point Courier font, scenes that are no longer than three pages, and strict adherence to a three-act structure can stifle the narrative flow and originality of a script. These rules often prioritize technical conformity over artistic expression, which is a potential threat to the film industry. Successful screenplays, such as Citizen Kane, Eraserhead, Reservoir Dogs, and Pulp Fiction, frequently break these very rules and yet manage to resonate and captivate audiences.

Why Break the Rules?

Breaking the rules is not about recklessly disregarding convention. It is about understanding the essence of your story and daring to express it in a unique way. Many of the most groundbreaking films have embraced unconventional storytelling techniques. For example, Eraserhead by David Lynch uses experimental narrative structures and surreal imagery to explore complex themes. Similarly, Quentin Tarantino’s Pulp Fiction breaks the linear narrative structure to create a fascinating and non-linear storyline.

Balancing Creativity and Technical Rules

Nuance is key when considering the balance between creativity and technical rules. While some rules are advisable to follow, such as adhering to a clear and concise narrative, others can be bent or broken depending on the needs of the story. For example, a flashbacks or voice-over devices might be used sparingly to enhance the narrative rather than hinder it. It is the responsibility of the writer to understand the purpose of each element and use it judiciously.

The Illusion of Industry Realities

The “priesthood” often rationalizes its rules by claiming they are rooted in the realities of the industry. However, this argument is often overblown. While it is true that some industry professionals may have limited time to read scripts, it is the quality and originality of the story that ultimately matter. Successful screenwriters must have the courage to break these rules when it serves the story, rather than compromising their vision for the sake of industry conventions.

The Future of Screenwriting

As the screenwriting “priesthood” continues to evolve, it is essential for writers to remain true to their creative vision. The key is to find a balance between adhering to necessary technical rules and pushing the boundaries of narrative and storytelling. By understanding the essence of your story and being willing to break the rules when it serves the narrative, you can create works that not only resonate with audiences but also stand the test of time.

Ultimately, the goal is not only to produce a script that conforms to industry standards but to create a story that is unique and compelling. As Peter Guber notes, producing good and interesting films should be the primary goal, and reclaiming the original inspiration of your story is the path to achieving that goal.