Is Arya the Smartest Stark?

The question of whether Arya Stark is the smartest character among her family is a complex one, as it depends on how we define 'smart'. While Arya has numerous traits that are often associated with intelligence and strategic thinking, a deeper look into her actions and decisions reveals a more nuanced picture.

The Emotional Decisions of Arya Stark

It is crucial to recognize that Arya's 'smartness' cannot be solely determined based on her emotional choices. Prior to Ned Stark's tragic demise, Arya often makes decisions driven by her intense emotions, rather than through a calculated, rational mindset. This emotional decision-making is particularly evident in her infamous choice to betray Weese.

Arya tells Jaqen H'ghar, 'You will kill three people for me,' and the obvious targets that come to mind are figures who pose a significant threat to the Stark family: Tywin Lannister, Cersei Lannister, and Roose Bolton, the formidable sons of the Kingdom's enemies. Yet, she chooses Weese, a common man at Harrenhal who had at most slapped her once. This impulsive and potentially dangerous decision does not align with what we might consider the epitome of 'smartness'.

Murder of Dareon: The Dark Path

The murders of Dareon by Arya, the Night's Watch deserter, serve as a harrowing illustration of her darker inclinations. In her mind, Dareon's desertion threatened Arya, so she lures him into an alley and kills him. This is not intended to be a 'badass' moment but a clear indication of Arya's dark path. Her actions in the books, which result in her losing her sight, are further proof that she lost her sense of ethics and responsibility, especially after betraying the Faceless Men with ease. In stark contrast, the TV show toned down these characteristics to account for Arya's fan-favorite status.

The Strategic Decisions of Other Starks

While Arya's decisions are often impulsive and emotional, other members of the Stark family excel in strategic and intelligent thinking. Let us consider Sansa Stark, who faces a similar challenging environment in King's Landing, yet thrives through her calculated decisions.

In contrast to her seemingly uncontrolled sister, Sansa has proven her intelligence in several instances. For instance, when Joffrey threatens to kill Ser Dantos on his nameday, she cleverly defuses the situation by suggesting it was "bad luck" to kill on someone's nameday. Similarly, her interactions with Littlefinger and Sweet Robin in the Vale showcase her growing cunning and strategic maneuvering.

Intelligence and Strategic Planning of Book Jon Snow

Beyond Arya and Sansa, Jon Snow (as depicted in the books) also stands as a testament to intellectual and strategic prowess. Unlike his televised counterpart, who is often portrayed inaccurately, Book Jon demonstrates significant intelligence. His ability to convince the Wildlings of his desertion from the Night's Watch and his strategic mind behind the defense of Castle Black are clear indications of his considerable wisdom.

Furthermore, Jon's work with Stannis Baratheon and obtaining funding from the Iron Bank are prime examples of his foresight and resourcefulness. These actions highlight his capacity for strategic planning and foresight, traits that are often overlooked in his TV portrayal.

Reflections on Ned Stark's Leadership

Ned Stark deserves a more considerate discussion about his intelligence and leadership. His reputation as a simpleton is largely a result of the plot decisions made by author George R.R. Martin. Under Ned's leadership, the North thrived with unprecedented peace and unity. His leadership style was so respected that once he was removed, the North descended into chaos. The phrase, 'When there was a Stark in Winterfell, a maiden girl could walk the kingsroad in her nameday gown and still go unmolested and travelers could find fire bread and salt at many an inn and holdfast,' underscores the respect and security Ned brought to the region.

It is not just his actions but also the overall stability and respect he commanded that indicate his intelligence and strategic thinking. This is not the mindset of a man unversed in the complexities of leadership and strategy.

Arya Stark: Not the Smartest, but Undeniably Resourceful

While Arya Starks does not top the list of the smartest members of her family based on strategic and calculated intelligence, she is undoubtedly resourceful and clever. Her struggles and survival despite her poor decision-making and unforced errors are testaments to her perseverance and adaptability.

In conclusion, the Stark family is a rich tapestry of personalities, each characterized by their unique brand of intelligence and wisdom. While Arya's 'smartness' is often overshadowed by her emotional and often chaotic decision-making, her resourcefulness and adaptability stand as significant contributions to her character and narrative.