Beyond Elizabeth Taylor: Other Actresses Who Could Have Portrayed Cleopatra in the 1963 Film

When we think of Cleopatra in film, Elizabeth Taylor's iconic portrayal often comes to mind. But who else could have made a compelling Cleopatra in the 1963 film adaptationand why?

Let's explore the best alternative choices beyond Elizabeth Taylor, including Sophia Loren, Joan Collins, Barbra Streisand, and Audrey Hepburn. Who would have done a better job, or would their looks and acting styles have made for a standout performance?

1. Sophia Loren: A Visual Choice for Cleopatra

Sophia Loren would have been an interesting choice for Cleopatra in the 1963 film. Known for her glamorous and ethereal looks, Sophia has an ‘ethnic' look to her due to her Italian origins, which would have suited the Egyptian empress. Her striking features and regal bearing would have effortlessly captured the essence of Cleopatra. However, the decision would have been complicated, considering her international appeal and the need to pass for someone from the Middle East.

The Challenge: Authenticity and Portrayal

While Sophia's appearance and style would have been a perfect fit for the role, the task of convincing audiences of her Egyptian heritage would have been challenging. Audiences would have had a hard time believing a European actress as Cleopatra, given the historical and cultural context. Yet, she would have brought a unique flair and allure to the character, elevating the production with her commanding stage presence.

2. Joanne Collins: A Bold and Confident Cleopatra

Joan Collins would have made a formidable Cleopatra. Known for her confidence and presence, she would have brought a strong and commanding energy to the role. Collins's ability to exude charm and power would have been particularly fitting for a historical figure such as Cleopatra. Her commanding voice, coupled with her striking looks, would have made every scene she's in electrifying.

The Challenge: Audience Reception and Stereotypes

Joyce Brooke Carroll, better known as Joan Collins, would have had to navigate stereotypes and expectations. Her portrayal would have been a risk, as it departed from the traditional European beauty standard. However, her performance would have been compelling, showcasing the depth and complexity of Cleopatra as a character. Collins is known for her ability to bring a dynamic and multifaceted quality to her characters, and Cleopatra would have been no exception.

3. Barbra Streisand: A Fresh and New Talent

Barbra Streisand is often credited as one of the best geniuses in film and music. Had Barbra been a part of the 1963 Cleopatra film, it would have been a groundbreaking move as she hadn't broken into films yet, making her portrayal of the character all the more impressive. Streisand's voice and acting ability would have added a unique depth and character to the role, positioning the film as a true multisensory experience.

The Challenge: Lack of Experience and Perception

With Streisand's lack of experience in film, bridging the gap between her established career as a singer and her newfound venture into acting would have been a challenge. However, her talent and charisma would have been enough to make the transition smooth. Barbra's ability to captivate audiences with her singing and her raw talent in acting would have been a game-changer, making her a formidable Cleopatra.

4. Audrey Hepburn: A Graceful and Elegant Choice

Often overlooked in the context of Cleopatra, Audrey Hepburn could have made an elegant and graceful Cleopatra. With her timeless beauty and poise, she would have brought a sense of regality and regal poise to the role of the Egyptian empress. Hepburn's ability to convey grace and inner strength would have been an asset in portraying Cleopatra's complexities.

The Challenge: Physical Attractiveness and Casting Vision

While Hepburn's charm and elegance would have been a great fit, the physicality and historical accuracy of the role would have been a challenge. Cleopatra was known for her strategic acumen, political prowess, and physical attractiveness, a combination that Hepburn would have had to embody. Audiences would have loved seeing Audrey Hepburn as Cleopatra, with her delicate features and refined disposition adding a touch of sophistication to the character.

Conclusion: The Lasting Impact of Elizabeth Taylor's Cleopatra

The 1963 film Cleopatra immortalized Elizabeth Taylor in the role of Cleopatra. Though she was not the only option, her choice was strategic and fitting. Each of the actresses mentioned here would have brought unique qualities and challenges to the role, but ultimately, Elizabeth Taylor made the role a timeless classic. Her portrayal continues to stand as a testament to the enduring power and charisma of this legendary actress.

Despite the numerous talented options, the decision to cast Elizabeth Taylor as Cleopatra remains a significant moment in film history. Her performance not only elevated the film but also set a new standard for future interpretations of the role. Whether it be Sophia Loren’s allure, Joan Collins’ confidence, Barbra Streisand’s fresh take, or Audrey Hepburn’s grace, each actress would have delivered an entertaining and compelling Cleopatra, each with their unique flair and style. The question remains: who would you have chosen, and why?

Note: This article is a hypothetical exploration and does not claim to change the historical facts of the movie's casting. It is an exercise in narrative imagination and audience perception analysis.